Discussion: Sugababes: The Essentials [Winner] - Page 38

prézli

Quote:

Originally posted by JustLuke

1. Never Gonna Dance Again
2. Whatever Makes You Happy
3. Gotta Be You

AMEN.

*puts Alexandra gif here*

Subomie

If at first you don't succeed...

... pick yourself up and try again.

Subomie

3.
Gotta Be You

8.364

Gotta Be You scores

This Try Again inspired crunk bop is actually Mutya's favourite song on Taller. It shows! She sounds somewhat invested for her verses on this (and they're fire), poor Red Dress! I think it was considered for a single but was cast aside for... Ugly and Follow Me Home. Yeah. No wonder Mutya bailed.

I know some people get down on it for being too similar to the song that it essentially is, but when that song is a 15/10 then who cares? I think it's fantastic and Mutya's parts are especially some of my favourite Suga moments. This never left the Top 3 throughout voting, but was never at #1 either. Always the bridesmaid, poor Mut-Mut

Taller in More Ways is a weird album. It was definitely a growth album, and a lot of changes happened here that changed the group for all future exploits. I can see why some love it and some hate it. The problem is that it has some absolute brilliant tracks next to some godawful tracks, and I think these results reflect that. I do appreciate that it was their maturing album, but sometimes I wish it was more solid and cohesive.

prézli

GOD IS REAL.

Subomie

There goes Taller In More Ways, taking my last 10 with her.

Vilppu

What a lame top 2

Lukey

Come on

Vilppu

This is kind of better than any Sugababes track.

prézli

I hate Amelle, but Never Gonna Dance Again FOR THE WIN!

BlueTimberwolf

The singles form Taller should have been. PTB, Ugly, GBY, and Ace.

Also, if the winner of this rate is a solo song......

Subomie

Should I do a eulogy for Mut-Mut? I mean, she does like background vocals on WMYH but like this was kinda the last song with her featured prominently on it.

RIP Best member and all-around kween, you built the Haus of Suga and even when you left your influence kept the house on solid foundations through the following rough years

Now join your bank accounts and leave us

Subomie

Quote:

Originally posted by Vilppu

This is kind of better than any Sugababes track.

Let me call Connor in here to clock your ass.

Subomie

so basically Keisha wins regardless, n.

BlueTimberwolf

While Mutya gets a lot of credit, I really think it was Keisha who had the most influence to make the group what they are today.

Subomie

I'll reveal the winner Page 39 but let's post our fave Mutya pics to get there.

Lukey

prézli

Quote:

Originally posted by BlueTimberwolf

While Mutya gets a lot of credit, I really think it was Keisha who had the most influence to make the group what they are today.

True.

Vilppu

Sle.

BlueTimberwolf

Muta looked her best during Taller in my opinion. I also like her red hair during part of the Three era

Subomie

Quote:

Originally posted by BlueTimberwolf

While Mutya gets a lot of credit, I really think it was Keisha who had the most influence to make the group what they are today.

Keisha was instrumental certainly, but I feel that Mutys better knew where to take the group. Her absence during the whole making of Taller is evident if you look at the era.

Keisha certainly made the band what it was for better or for worse but I think she also has the burden of causing it to implode upon itself too.

No shade though, I love all 6 members.