[Brando]

Originally posted by J a y

I'd say it was overrated!

The episode was a nice intro but it lacked in places. I said this before I even read the critics.

I'm not however accepting fault on Gaga's part when she's 5% of the show.

What about the rest of the cast? Bad acting too? How's everyone still interested after 4 seasons?

No logic.

Oh come on Jay, we know you are one of the better Monsters on the site and don't do the silly things others do, but you damn well know what this thread would have looked like if it was the highest rated season. "Queen of critics", "Another day, another slay" etc regardless of how much of it was due to Gaga's involvement.

Personally, I haven't watched it, so I don't have an opinion on it, but the comments here are funny nonetheless

[halcyonday]

Originally posted by Brando

The defensiveness and the hypocrisy, I can't

If this was the highest rated AHS season would the monsters be saying "This has nothing to do with Gaga, but the show overall" or would they be saying "Critical darling", "Queen of ratings", etc etc?

I love this website for the laughs it provides

[SupahBass05]

The meltdowns RT audience score is down to 71%.

EDIT: 69%

[GreatCoolBright]

Originally posted by ivi

this is about the reviews, not the ratings aka the views.

ohh sorry. do we know the ratings yet?

[GreatCoolBright]

Originally posted by Brando

I think you both copy-and-pasted the wrong excuses

what the **** are you talking about

[ProudtobeLoud]

The whole episode was boring. The best part was Hotel California playing at the end

[Kitt]

[ivi]

Originally posted by GreatCoolBright

ohh sorry. do we know the ratings yet?

nope they should be out in a few hours

[Joan]

Some of you literally have no lives Monsters,good sistrens, please leave the thread and don't worry yourself over pettiness

[all eyes on me]

it wasnt that great lbr
it wasnt atrocious

i hated murder houses first episode i think the fair thing would be just to wait and see where it goes

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by Brando

Oh come on Jay, we know you are one of the better Monsters on the site and don't do the silly things others do, but you damn well know what this thread would have looked like if it was the highest rated season. "Queen of critics", "Another day, another slay" etc regardless of how much of it was due to Gaga's involvement.

Personally, I haven't watched it, so I don't have an opinion on it, but the comments here are funny nonetheless

Robbie/XOXO must be rolling on the floor laughing after all the grief the Monsters gave him before the pilot aired.

I haven't watched it yet but I'm surprised that the ratings are so low. But then again, singing a song at the Oscars and walking a red carpet looking stunning doesn't really say much about acting chops.

The AHS cast members were all praising GaGa's acting ability but according to those who have watched, she was more than awkward in her scenes. I'm guessing the other actors were just talking her up in interviews cuz she was so nice on set. Riding the "nice" wave can get you far even if the actual skill is lacking.

[theworldfamous]

I love that ATRL has suddenly become this prestigious forum where everyone has a BFA in Acting and Cinema

Of course the usual trolls have found their way in here

[TheEdgeOfGaga]

Okay so this was semi-decent. Better than FreakShow but the storyline is kinda boring me so far. Will definitely check out the next episode but I don't know if I'll continue with the full season.

It's obvious Ryan has put more thought into Scream Queens (rightfully so).

[Scene.]

No one cares about RT or Metacritic ratings.

[Notorious K.E.N]

How weren't the ratings huge? It had one of the biggest and most extensive promos so far

Plus gaga always brings in ratings

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Notorious K.E.N

How weren't the ratings huge? It had one of the biggest and most extensive promos so far

Plus gaga always brings in ratings

You're not talking about the same ratings, here.

[ScarletWitch]

Originally posted by Tanguy

You're not talking about the same ratings, here.

The blind haters running into a Gaga-related thread just to drag without reading

[Nutitle]

Originally posted by Brando

The defensiveness and the hypocrisy, I can't

If this was the highest rated AHS season would the monsters be saying "This has nothing to do with Gaga, but the show overall" or would they be saying "Critical darling", "Queen of ratings", etc etc?

I love this website for the laughs it provides

But unlike YOU trolls and haters, most of us say it as a JOKE, when we say "Queen of ___" it's a JOKE, when we say "AHS: Lady Gaga" it's a JOKE, same when we say "AHS: Mattress"

Y'all take the monsters TOO seriously, it's embarrassing tbh, move on already

[Blue Jeans]

You know what. I don't care about success and ratings. I'm enjoying it, and that's what matters. Tired of that pretentiousness and caring about ratings/success. Gaga has had it all. Just enjoy

[jcsfreebitch]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Robbie/XOXO must be rolling on the floor laughing after all the grief the Monsters gave him before the pilot aired.

I haven't watched it yet but I'm surprised that the ratings are so low. But then again, singing a song at the Oscars and walking a red carpet looking stunning doesn't really say much about acting chops.

The AHS cast members were all praising GaGa's acting ability but according to those who have watched, she was more than awkward in her scenes. I'm guessing the other actors were just talking her up in interviews cuz she was so nice on set. Riding the "nice" wave can get you far even if the actual skill is lacking.

Calm down lol