Grace as the killer would be reeeeeeally interesting. Issues: she saw the devil 'stalking' her the first night. Guess it could've been a random/someone else standing about menacingly then vanishing for no reason, but she then accused boring guy of being the devil when she saw his costume, which she claimed not to know was the school mascot. She could have been lying about not knowing what it was, but that's a bit pointless since it didn't achieve anything.
+1 Didn't she also call it the killer before anyone knew it was a guy in a red devil custome?
+1 Didn't she also call it the killer before anyone knew it was a guy in a red devil custome?
Grace is fishy to me.
Chanel #2 tweeted about being stabbed to death by the Red Devil before Grace found the costume in his closet. While Dean Munsch didn't know immediately that #2 had been killed, it's not a stretch to assume that the younger characters would have found out.
I wouldn't say it's cliche because almost all those movies are unknowns but a twist like that definitely isn't groundbreaking. Also, I'm sure no matter who the killer is there will be disappointment from some members anyway.
Yall have to give them time, everyone is trying to prove theories, talking about which characters are basic and which aren't, which ones they want to make it til the end and it only premiered a few days ago. We have months to go