Quote:
Originally posted by conatus
Just wait. I'm honestly thinking about raising a couple of my scores in case they get rejected for trolling. (See: Mariah discography rate, It Girls of 2001 rate, etc.)
|
Someone gave every single song on her debut a 1 and I didn't reject their scores because the rest of their scores seemed thought out and legit. Just don't go crazy and we're cool.
Quote:
Originally posted by Travis Bickle
The spam  . This is not a chat.
Madonna rates are always ruined here thanks to her haters. It will not take long to appear that member who always gives her zeros  Like, at least try to hide your bitterness Lol |
Well everyone only gets one zero and all the rates so far seem to be coming from fans. There is so much unreleased stuff here that you would have to be a fan to get through all the songs. And the whole point of a rate is to discuss what songs you like best and which songs you dislike so I don't see how it wouldn't be a chat. Just because a discussion isn't happening in the Madonna base doesn't mean it is off topic. Plus I'm happy for a discussion here. It means that the thread gets bumped without me having to make up an awkward reason to bump it. I would have participated in the discussion too if I weren't busy when it was happening.
Quote:
Originally posted by Mr. Fahrenheit
OP should have put the pre-Sire stuff into the 'Extras' category instead of under Madonna.  |
Yeah, I went back and forth, but I decided to put them with the debut just because of chronology and so it would have more than just 3 songs. For the final album averages, I'm gonna do them like I have organized currently and I'll reveal how they placed without the b-sides, demos, and regional/not-super-easy-to-get bonus tracks (all of which will go towards the extras average in that instance).
Some of the really bad non-singles and the dodgier unreleased cuts dragged down scores (especially from the '80s - OP should have put the pre-Sire stuff into the 'Extras' category instead of under Madonna). Plus, you know, sometimes a bad song is a bad song. She ain't infallible. 
