[minho]

Originally posted by Sam 

Everything comes back to Beyoncé. It's Beyoncé's world, we're just living in it.

True <3

[Aurora]

I listened to B'Day and Blackout for the first time for Prismatic's rate (I know most ATRLers would skin me alive for admitting I hadn't listened to those albums before now, but alas) and I actually liked Blackout more than B'Day.

[minho]

Originally posted by Sam 

I listened to B'Day and Blackout for the first time for Prismatic's rate (I know most ATRLers would skin me alive for admitting I hadn't listened to those albums before now, but alas) and I actually liked Blackout more than B'Day.

....
............
...
.......





....

I thought Blackout was the most uneventful album ever. I had such high expectations but I was so let down outside of like 2 songs which I find out are the least favourites among most people. B'day > imo

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by Sam 

I listened to B'Day and Blackout for the first time for Prismatic's rate (I know most ATRLers would skin me alive for admitting I hadn't listened to those albums before now, but alas) and I actually liked Blackout more than B'Day.

Sis that rate was the first and last time I have ever listened to either of those albums. The way I dragged everyone in that rate who doesn't use a stage name.


Britney had like two really good songs I was shocked.


Bday didn't impress me other than "Listen." A few others were decent, but...

[Subomie]

B'Day is ok. There's a lot of treasure in there but some trash too (especially the bonus tracks in the rate).


Blackout is nice but idk, I never get the godly aura that ATRL puts around it. Still good though!

[Citrus]

B'Day is so forgettable tho

[Subomie]

Originally posted by lovesong

....
............
...
.......





....

I thought Blackout was the most uneventful album ever. I had such high expectations but I was so let down outside of like 2 songs which I find out are the least favourites among most people. B'day > imo

which two

[Subomie]

B'Day has Get Me Bodied, of which the extended dance break is the best moment of Bey's career.

[minho]

Originally posted by Subomie

which two

Get Naked and Why Should I Be Sad

[Subomie]

Originally posted by lovesong

Get Naked and Why Should I Be Sad

Yay, those are career highlights. They're actually fan favourites too, the taste in that rate is just... weird.

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by Subomie

B'Day is ok. There's a lot of treasure in there but some trash too (especially the bonus tracks in the rate).


Blackout is nice but idk, I never get the godly aura that ATRL puts around it. Still good though!

Makes you wonder if ATRL would even talk about it if it hadn't been for the whole meltdown — radio blacklisting — Billboard 200 snub.

Originally posted by Citrus

B'Day is so forgettable tho

I've always been under the impression that all of her pre-2010 albums were not good. So far, I've found this to be true. I haven't heard the Crazy in Love album yet, though.



LMAO, which breathe heavy bot invented the fantasy that is the legacy section on Blackout's wiki page?

[Aurora]

Originally posted by Subomie

B'Day has Get Me Bodied, of which the extended dance break is the best moment of Bey's career.

I gave that song the lowest score of the entire rate, a 4.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by JakeKills

I've always been under the impression that all of her pre-2010 albums were not good. So far, I've found this to be true. I haven't heard the Crazy in Love album yet, though.

Basically true. B'Day is decent but the deluxe edition is a sin against god. Sasha Fierce is tripe and a massive waste of time. Her debut has some cute album tracks but there's a bunch of bad tracks dragging down.

That said, those albums are still in the upper tier when it comes to pop girl releases so

[Aurora]

Originally posted by lovesong

Get Naked and Why Should I Be Sad

I think I gave Get Naked a 5 and Why Should I Be Sad a 4 (tied lowest with Get Me Bodied)

[Achilles.]

I only really liked Radar and Piece of Me.

[Subomie]

I maintain that Radar is the best song on Circus

[Citrus]

Piece of Me, Freakshow, Gimme More, and Break the Ice are flawless. I forgot how hard I stan.

[Aurora]

Songs I loved (received score of 9 or above):

Ring The Alarm
Freakum Dress
Umbrella
Don't Stop The Music
Breakin' Dishes
Shut Up And Drive
Hate That I Love You
Disturbia
Take A Bow
Gimme More
Piece Of Me
Radar
Toy Solider
Bad Romance
Alejandro
Monster
Dance In The Dark
Telephone

I think I was pretty generous.

[minho]

I really did not enjoy GGGB. I don't really like Rihanna pre-Loud though.

[Achilles.]

All of my top songs are on your list except for Listen and So Happy I Could Die.