[Penny.]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

Eh. I think most of them got bored of the base, not really the band.

They were there for the UAN/TMH sound.... which is very different than the Four sound.

who else left? bambi still posts sometimes & dimaond flaked as we all expected & jack left but who else?

yea theyve changed a lot which is why i laugh so hard when people on here try to say all 4 albums sound exactly the same

[Wafflecakes]

I prefer their more pop sound. They really cannot pull off a rock sound imo

Plus I don't feel like they changed sounds because they thought the new sound was better, I feel like they changed because they were getting too cool for pop.

Which is why I hope they go back a bit now that Zayn is gone

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

I prefer their more pop sound. They really cannot pull off a rock sound imo

Plus I don't feel like they changed sounds because they thought the new sound was better, I feel like they changed because they were getting too cool for pop.

Which is why I hope they go back a bit now that Zayn is gone

i disagree

i think they changed cos the music they do now is more like what kind of music they listen to themselves & want to do
i would be here for more pop songs on 1D5 tho cos their pop sound was incredible
& with zayn gone that means more vocals for them all which means even more harry

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by Penny.

who else left? bambi still posts sometimes & dimaond flaked as we all expected & jack left but who else?

yea theyve changed a lot which is why i laugh so hard when people on here try to say all 4 albums sound exactly the same

You weren't really around for the original base. I am probably the only active member from the early original thread left.

MWB, Regina, Jack!, Icarus, Jungle, Rudeboy, Serendipity, Naughty.....

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by Penny.

i disagree

i think they changed cos the music they do now is more like what kind of music they listen to themselves & want to do
i would be here for more pop songs on 1D5 tho cos their pop sound was incredible
& with zayn gone that means more vocals for them all which means even more harry

Either way, a 3rd album of that sound would be a huge mistake.

They need to do something different with this album.

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

You weren't really around for the original base. I am probably the only active member from the early original thread left.

MWB, Regina, Jack!, Icarus, Jungle, Rudeboy, Serendipity, Naughty.....

oh yes MWB i miss him
naughty dog or w/e? oh god no i am sooooooooooo glad he is gone
he is disgusting the things he says i cannot stand him
wasnt regina thread banned or something?
rudeboy i miss but he still posts here & there as Promotheus

[Wafflecakes]

These were my two favorite 1D gifs back in the VERY early days, before I even found the ATRL base.

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

Either way, a 3rd album of that sound would be a huge mistake.

They need to do something different with this album.

i do agree with this & i think they will
especially now that they have one member gone
i think they will bring something new

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by Penny.

oh yes MWB i miss him
naughty dog or w/e? oh god no i am sooooooooooo glad he is gone
he is disgusting the things he says i cannot stand him
wasnt regina thread banned or something?
rudeboy i miss but he still posts here & there as Promotheus

Naughty just developed a bad attitude. He use to be nice/fun.

Regina had fights with everyone. She kind of stopped posted after we fought that last time... though I have gotten over it and and wish she would come back

....and yeah. Jack!, Prometheous, and Jungle are still around.



... then I got Bie perma-thread banned

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

These were my two favorite 1D gifs back in the VERY early days, before I even found the ATRL base.

the first louis one is iconic
i have sooooooooooo many favorite 1D gifs
this one is perfect

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by Penny.

i do agree with this & i think they will
especially now that they have one member gone
i think they will bring something new

I just want it to be very upbeat. Their last two albums have been very mid-tempo.

They can do that with any sound.

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

Naughty just developed a bad attitude. He use to be nice/fun.

Regina had fights with everyone. She kind of stopped posted after we fought that last time... though I have gotten over and and wish she would come back

....and yeah. Jack!, Prometheous, and Jungle are still around.



... then I got Bie perma-thread banned

i cant imagine him being nice tbh wth happened to him

u should tell her that

he is perma banned?

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by Penny.

i cant imagine him being nice tbh wth happened to him

u should tell her that

he is perma banned?

I don't want ha back THAT much

There was so much drama back then. Wayyyy more than now, and way meaner, but we also had more fun.


...and yeah. You only get so many thread bans before it becomes perma (like 8 I think?).




As to Naughty. I actually posted in Popgaf on Neogaf with him long before I really started posting on ATRL. We were good friends (imo) for a while. We would hang out and chat on plug.dj for hours and PM back and forth on the forums.

Then one day he turned into kind of a bitch

One day we were friendly. The next day he had dropped me and almost never talked to me

[perfectly.ill]

The only hint we have about the next album is that one of the songs reminds Liam of Oasis. Which I'm perfectly okay with.

[Wafflecakes]

Back in the day I would post:



As a virtual hug to Naughty since I stanned Louis, while he was a Zayn stan.

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by perfectly.ill

The only hint we have about the next album is that one of the songs reminds Liam of Oasis. Which I'm perfectly okay with.

I need to listed to Oasis then. I don't remember how it sounds

[£than]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

Has anyone listened to Shawn Mendes? He reminds me a lot of early 1D

Late.
I need the boys to blatantly rip Ryn off with the next album cause they would kill Traveling Song/Here Is Home.

[Vespertine]

Originally posted by perfectly.ill

The only hint we have about the next album is that one of the songs reminds Liam of Oasis. Which I'm perfectly okay with.

Have the Gallaghers heard of this yet? They'll fume and drag.

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Vespertine

Have the Gallaghers heard of this yet? They'll fume and drag.

surprisingly he was rather calm about it tbh
http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-en...-10226331.html

& im here for the oasis-y sound as well cos oasis has some amazing songs

[Penny.]

Originally posted by Waffles O'Brien

I don't want ha back THAT much

There was so much drama back then. Wayyyy more than now, and way meaner, but we also had more fun.


...and yeah. You only get so many thread bans before it becomes perma (like 8 I think?).




As to Naughty. I actually posted in Popgaf on Neogaf with him long before I really started posting on ATRL. We were good friends (imo) for a while. We would hang out and chat on plug.dj for hours and PM back and forth on the forums.

Then one day he turned into kind of a bitch

One day we were friendly. The next day he had dropped me and almost never talked to me

ok i see

& wow idk bie was perma'd poor ha
he goes around trying to drag harry now anyways so he deserves it
plus he called me penis

omg really? i wonder what his problem is
he is honestly the worst member here now imo