[Jack!]

I understand what Jessica is saying, we just need to wait and see with Gaga, but she's surrounded with good people.

I feel like Jessica says everything in a certain way that it can come off a certain way in writing, but I don't think she was saying what she was saying in a horrible way. And really, if she has a problem with Gaga doing the series, that's her issue - she didn't need to leave the show. Just saying.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

I mean, EYE spilled that tea COUNTLESS times and probably over a hundred pages ago, and y'all would never get off of my NECK. And I did it with as much (or as little, I guess) intent to shade as Jessica just did. But because I'm not a hardcore Monster (or a celebrity), I guess it means I'm just trying to discredit Gaga "Wherever I can" (Despite only ever getting at the one ****ing point: That we don't know if she can even act in a serious role and I think it's unfair that her debut as such is so demanding already).

[LadyLana]

Originally posted by X/O/X/O

I mean, EYE spilled that tea COUNTLESS times and probably over a hundred pages ago, and y'all would never get off of my NECK. And I did it with as much (or as little, I guess) intent to shade as Jessica just did. But because I'm not a hardcore Monster (or a celebrity), I guess it means I'm just trying to discredit Gaga "Wherever I can" (Despite only ever getting at the one ****ing point: That we don't know if she can even act in a serious role and I think it's unfair that her debut as such is so demanding already).

I think people had an issue with how often you were discrediting her, rather than your actual comment
I'm nervous for Gaga though... I've never thought she was a great actress. She's not awful, but I don't think she can lead an entire show. I guess we'll see

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by LadyLana

I think people had an issue with how often you were discrediting her, rather than your actual comment
I'm nervous for Gaga though... I've never thought she was a great actress. She's not awful, but I don't think she can lead an entire show. I guess we'll see

More proof that they weren't listening, because I've said time and time again that I wasn't doing it in bias against Gaga but out of actual concern for the TV show for the reason stated above, but no one listened.

[Haus]

Originally posted by X/O/X/O

More proof that they weren't listening, because I've said time and time again that I wasn't doing it in bias against Gaga but out of actual concern for the TV show for the reason stated above, but no one listened.

You reiterated your point so many times that it looked like it was bias against GaGa. We all heard you.

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by X/O/X/O

More proof that they weren't listening, because I've said time and time again that I wasn't doing it in bias against Gaga but out of actual concern for the TV show for the reason stated above, but no one listened.

Can you blame them? You routinely call her fat in SYG.

[Jack!]

Bbb now girls, let's not do this. Robbie is still right in what he's saying, and regardless of whether or not he's being biased, no one can look at two to three cameo roles and certify Gaga as good enough to front an entire series of a show.

With that being said, I thought Ryan said Kathy was taking the lead, but I guess we'll need to wait for further information.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by Haus

You reiterated your point so many times that it looked like it was bias against GaGa. We all heard you.

Then that's y'all's misjudgment. You gonna clock Jessica Lange, too?

Originally posted by BTrisc

Can you blame them? You routinely call her fat in SYG.

Idk what "routinely" means to you, but I never come for anyone's size in SYG (Other than Kelly Clarkson), and the one time I did call Gaga "fat", I was kidding, because she looked thinner than ever in the photo I was quoting.

[Tylerbv]

Is everyone suddenly seeing the POV that Gaga can't replace an acting legend?
Fishy.

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by X/O/X/O

Then that's y'all's misjudgment. You gonna clock Jessica Lange, too?

Idk what "routinely" means to you, but I never come for anyone's size in SYG (Other than Kelly Clarkson), and the one time I did call Gaga "fat", I was kidding, because she looked thinner than ever in the photo I was quoting.

I mean, am not offended, but you can't act surprised especially after
you compare your current perception of Gags to your former stan days.

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by Tylerbv

Is everyone suddenly seeing the POV that Gaga can't replace an acting legend?
Fishy.

Unless Gaga's playing a 50+ year old bat chasing after her former youth, I don't think anyone actually believes she's replacing Jessica.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by BTrisc

I mean, am not offended, but you can't act surprised especially after
you compare your current perception of Gags to your former stan days.

I was not resilient enough to tolerate a majority of the BTW era, and everything about the ARTPOP era save for the music itself (bar 4 songs) & the GUY video. Do you blame me for that?

You shoulda seen me getting my life listening to TFM for the first time in a few months in SYG about a month or two ago.

[Jack!]

The only issue Ryan made with casting Gaga is the imminent fan wars. I already can pick out for you 5-10 names that'll be here on series premiere night telling us how Gaga is going to ruin the show, regardless of how well she performs.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Another reiteration:

My problem is not with Gaga, it's with Ryan casting Gaga. If Gaga is not a good actress, it's not necessarily her fault for joining the show. But Ryan's a hot mess for casting her in a main role. He shoulda tested the waters and had her be a special guest in Freak Show instead of NPH. Ryan is my main issue with anything AHS (ironically, since he's the reason it exists). He's too quick to ruin his shows through pandering and idiotic attempts to be edgy, among other things.

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by X/O/X/O

I was not resilient enough to tolerate a majority of the BTW era, and everything about the ARTPOP era save for the music itself (bar 4 songs) & the GUY video. Do you blame me for that?

You shoulda seen me getting my life listening to TFM for the first time in a few months in SYG about a month or two ago.

Well you can count Ryan's blessings and be thankful that this season is shaping up
to be super gothic and disturbing. The Monster Ball interludes who?

[Skywalker]

x/o/x/o u are being so abrasive

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by BTrisc

Well you can count Ryan's blessings and be thankful that this season is shaping up
to be super gothic and disturbing. The Monster Ball interludes who?

Michael Goi's comment got me excited. I'm also really excited for Wes, Chloe & Matt in the main cast. And for Sarah to finally not be the underdog who... ends up perfectly fine.

[BTrisc]

Actual footage of X/O/X/O contemplating ha life after Gags slays the first episode:

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by BTrisc

Actual footage of X/O/X/O contemplating ha life after Gags slays the first episode:

More like actual footage of me hiding in the bathroom during my dance class on my phone trying to read the ****ing thread after the announcement was initially made.

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by X/O/X/O

Michael Goi's comment got me excited. I'm also really excited for Wes, Chloe & Matt in the main cast. And for Sarah to finally not be the underdog who... ends up perfectly fine.

I'm actually most uncomfortable about Max. Like, Gaga can pull off the ambience regardless
of how good her acting chops are, but Max is going to stick out like Rude Boy @ the KCA's.