I mean, when has Bey ever hit a G5 with her chest voice? An A5 with her head voice? Ask clerk, he will tell you, nevah!
Good singing is not about hitting high notes. Being able to sing a higher note than someone else in whatever context does not make you a better vocalist. In the case of Tamar vs. Beyonce, Tamar is a soprano (HIGH voice) and Beyonce is a mezzo (LOWER,/MIDDLE voice). If you're going to play that game, then we might as well talk about Tamar's oxygen-ass low notes - no shade! Her kind of voice shouldn't be expected to have the most solid lower range.
Everything about Beyonce's singing, her breathing, her belting and projection/placement, her tone production, her mix, her agility, her musicality and creativity with improvisation - A1 steak sauce.
Tamar is a pitchy, airy, shouty, thin, shaky mess live. We know this. I think her voice is beautiful, but her live singing is not untouchable. Beyonce's kinda is - certainly at this point.
Good singing is not about hitting high notes. Being able to sing a higher note than someone else in whatever context does not make you a better vocalist. In the case of Tamar vs. Beyonce, Tamar is a soprano (HIGH voice) and Beyonce is a mezzo (LOWER,/MIDDLE voice). If you're going to play that game, then we might as well talk about Tamar's oxygen-ass low notes - no shade! Her kind of voice shouldn't be expected to have the most solid lower range.
Everything about Beyonce's singing, her breathing, her belting and projection/placement, her tone production, her mix, her agility, her musicality and creativity with improvisation - A1 steak sauce.
Tamar is a pitchy, airy, shouty mess live. We know this. I think her voice is beautiful, but her live singing is not untouchable. Beyonce's kinda is - certainly at this point.
Good singing is not about hitting high notes. Being able to sing a higher note than someone else in whatever context does not make you a better vocalist. In the case of Tamar vs. Beyonce, Tamar is a soprano (HIGH voice) and Beyonce is a mezzo (LOWER,/MIDDLE voice). If you're going to play that game, then we might as well talk about Tamar's oxygen-ass low notes - no shade! Her kind of voice shouldn't be expected to have the most solid lower range.
Everything about Beyonce's singing, her breathing, her belting and projection/placement, her tone production, her mix, her agility, her musicality and creativity with improvisation - A1 steak sauce.
Tamar is a pitchy, airy, shouty mess live. We know this. I think her voice is beautiful, but her live singing is not untouchable. Beyonce's kinda is - certainly at this point.
Clarke, as a self proclaimed vocal expert please explained to me how "overrated" "comparable to tinashe" "average" Ariana can do this?
Good singing is not about hitting high notes. Being able to sing a higher note than someone else in whatever context does not make you a better vocalist. In the case of Tamar vs. Beyonce, Tamar is a soprano (HIGH voice) and Beyonce is a mezzo (LOWER,/MIDDLE voice). If you're going to play that game, then we might as well talk about Tamar's oxygen-ass low notes - no shade! Her kind of voice shouldn't be expected to have the most solid lower range.
Everything about Beyonce's singing, her breathing, her belting and projection/placement, her tone production, her mix, her agility, her musicality and creativity with improvisation, her inability to write songs - A1 steak sauce.
Tamar is a pitchy, airy, shouty, thin, shaky mess live. We know this. I think her voice is beautiful, but her live singing is not untouchable. Beyonce's kinda is - certainly at this point.
Clarke, as a self proclaimed vocal expert please explained to me how "overrated" "comparable to tinashe" "average" Ariana can do this?
I am NOT a self-proclaimed expert. I routinely state that I am not even a vocal pedagogy student, just one who sings a lot and reads/talks a lot about singing on the web lol! My knowledge has grown a lot, but if I don't know what to say, I will make that clear.
In that video she's just belting a bunch of high notes. Those G5s and C6s should be relatively easy for a soprano! Her placement is still horizontal and backward and her voice is already small, so it's not like those high notes were HUGE or anything.
she just servin good drama
And I think Tinashe's a great singer. I've never seen a bad performance.
I am NOT a self-proclaimed expert. I routinely state that I am not even a vocal pedagogy student, just one who sings a lot and reads/talks a lot about singing on the web lol! My knowledge has grown a lot, but if I don't know what to say, I will make that clear.
In that video she's just belting a bunch of high notes. Those G5s and C6s should be relatively easy for a soprano! Her placement is still horizontal and backward and her voice is already small, so it's not like those high notes were HUGE or anything.
she just servin good drama
And I think Tinashe's a great singer. I've never seen a bad performance.
Tinashe sucks imo, she either lip syncs or sound flatter than a wall. I'm just saying, those we;re some good notes. For the way you we're talking about Ari before you'd think she was some karoke singer. Lol at "she's just belting a bunch of high notes". What do you expect her to sing? Low notes? As shown in that video of Beyonce damn near choking on a BB5 Ariana can sing effortless different artists have different range.
I feel you secretly stan for Ari, but you're too afraid to admit it. It's ok, we won't judge you.
