[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by XXXO

impact is subjective sis.

maybe for you it was so impactful and stuff but for the rest it wasnt.

I'm talking about the GP and how they reacted to her.

Can you tell me how Taylor wins in the Impact field?

Originally posted by atishvaze

I'm sorry but this is just laughable and kinda desperate

Then tell me atishvaze, how does Taylor win in the impact field? I'll wait.

Why are you trying so hard to make her win in everything? I can feel the bitterness

[atishvaze]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

Then tell me atishvaze, how does Taylor win in the impact field? I'll wait.

Why are you trying so hard to make her win in everything? I can feel the bitterness

Why would I try to argue 1989's impact when it's a measurable factor thus pointless.
Sales and acclaim are enough to support my point

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by atishvaze

I'm sorry but this is just laughable and kinda desperate

I just.....

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by atishvaze

TD ex USA: ~2.9 - 3M
1989: 3M - 3.2M

Mediatraffic:

1989
4.8M US - 7.2M WW
= 2.4M outside the US

TD
2.9M US - 6.5M WW
= 3.6M outside the US

Don't make up your own receipts, it's not a cute look.

[Ben.M.]

The one with 60M singles sold.

Also Imagine TD's sales with TEA and SEA

[Ash12345]

We shouldn't really be comparing 1989 after 7 months to TD after over a 2 year long era and 5 years after album release
Give 1989 some time to actually finish lol

[HumanitySector]

TD actually felt important and had some good songs.

[atishvaze]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

Mediatraffic:

1989
4.8M US - 7.2M WW
= 2.4M outside the US

TD
2.9M US - 6.5M WW
= 3.6M outside the US

Don't make up your own receipts, it's not a cute look.

IFPI = 8M. Which is more reliable?
And the era isn't over yet. She's gonna demolish TD when all is said and done and she doesn't even need a re-release.

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by atishvaze

Why would I try to argue 1989's impact when it's a measurable factor thus pointless.
Sales and acclaim are enough to support my point

Yet you had a different opinion in the other IKAG thread. Interesting

What point are you trying to make? because we both agree Taylor is winning but it seems like you're clutching at straws.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

There's no need to discuss about impact since us Taylor stans will say it's her (well not really coz she'd win without it as well) and kitty kats will obviously (lol) say katy wins

still can't @ boobs tho

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by atishvaze

IFPI = 8M. Which is more reliable?

Oh that's cute and where did you get your TD receipt then?

[Madonno]

1989
Acclaim, Awards, Sales, etc

[atishvaze]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

Oh that's cute and where did you get your TD receipt then?

Are you really trying to use the album receipts when you yourself posted this

1989: 7.2M
TD: 6.5M

I can't. Talk about trying to make your fave win in everything

[YR.]

1989 is almost at 8 million copies, this thread is pointless

It's 1989

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

There's no need to discuss about impact since us Taylor stans will say it's her (well not really coz she'd win without it as well) and kitty kats will obviously (lol) say katy wins

still can't @ boobs tho

Then why are people constantly saying Katy is only successful for her "boobs"?


Released September 2010
76,328,791 views








etc

Your turn.

[Samuel]

Albums: 1989
Singles: TD
Acclaim: 1989
Touring: 1989
Impact: TD

Tough! But I suppose 1989 wins, although I think TD will be more remembered by the GP in years to come.

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by atishvaze

Are you really trying to use the album receipts when you yourself posted this

1989: 7.2M
TD: 6.5M

I can't. Talk about trying to make your fave win in everything

You used IFPI for Taylor and then used your own receipts for Katy then I clocked you with MT.

How am I making my fave win in everything when Taylor won in more fields in my post? you're literally making no sense.

[atishvaze]

death at those pictures supposed to prove its impact. I could literally post loads of pics of fans wearing Taylor costumes while waiting in line for her concert or celebrities posting vids and stuff singing along to her singles but that would be too embarrassing

[Artemisia]

1989

[AMENHOOKER]

Originally posted by HumanitySector

TD actually felt important and had some good songs.

Felt important to whom?
You?

'1989' has sold more copies in just 7 months with 3 #1s than 'Teenage Dream' has after almost half a decade, after a re-release, a movie, 6 #1s singles and a Super Bowl performance showcasing its hits to 118 million viewers.

Feelings really don't belong in this thread.