[conatus]

Originally posted by Subomie

The whole Daydream era is boring, there's some gems on it like Underneath the Stars and Long Ago, but it's really one of her more middle-of-the-road albums. Sorry bout it.

I always considered it as one of my favourite Mariah albums, but when I sat down and actually listened to it in the context of her discography... It's not that great.

[enxe]

Originally posted by conatus

I always considered it as one of my favourite Mariah albums, but when I sat down and actually listened to it in the context of her discography... It's not that great.

I mean, is in your opinion any MC album great?

[conatus]

Originally posted by enxe

I mean, is in your opinion any MC album great?

Butterfly is one of my favourite albums, don't try it.

[conatus]

Everyone can try and drag me for being conservative with my scores, but considering there's 150+ songs in this rate, I'm not just going to hand out 10s here and there.

[Fantasea]

Long Ago is trash

[feelslikeadream]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

Yeah. This rate really increased my appreciation to about 5 songs:

-Music Box
-And You Don't Remember
-Looking In (I used to HATE it )
-Get Your Number
-Side Effects

If you'd like to give Side Effects your 11, let me know

Originally posted by Touchdown

Feellikeadream you've done an amazing job with this thread and idea and can't wait to see the results.

Originally posted by STMG23

Congrats also from me Feellikeadream! Without the results having started I can say that you did an amazing job in hyping and organizing it!

Originally posted by Superiore

I mean, which other rate got 174 pages before even starting? Most would dream to END with this number of pages.

Thanks y'all Remember that all I did so far was launch it, keep all the scores in a spreadsheet, and do some light advertising. The thread is a success so far because of all of you coming to comment and share your appreciation (and occasional distaste) of MC's incredible discography.



Anyway, I stayed off ATRL for the last few hours and managed to write 10/15 pages of one paper and 4/10 of the other, so now I'm getting back to work so that I can be done by tomorrow to kick the rate off right. I'll probably be up all night writing, so I'll check in to collect the last minute rates! (Sissy, I'm looking at you!)

[BeBeMint]

Originally posted by Subomie

The whole Daydream era is boring, there's some gems on it like Underneath the Stars and Long Ago, but it's really one of her more middle-of-the-road albums. Sorry bout it.

Finally someone who agrees with me. Theres like 4 good songs on Daydream Charmbracelet>>>>>

[Sissy]

Originally posted by feelslikeadream

Sissy, I'm looking at you!

Open your inbox to get slayed by my scores, dahhlin!

[Rocket]

Let me just remember how to spell it.

C O N A T U S.

I'll be typing that name many a times, because you sis, will be dragged to the fiery pits of hell when this rate kicks off.

[feelslikeadream]

Originally posted by Rocket

Let me just remember how to spell it.

C O N A T U S.

I'll be typing that name many a times, because you sis, will be dragged to the fiery pits of hell when this rate kicks off.

You won't need to remember how to spell it since it'll be popping up REPEATEDLY in the rate under the "Lowest Score" reveal for each song

[BeBeMint]

Originally posted by Rocket

Let me just remember how to spell it.

C O N A T U S.

I'll be typing that name many a times, because you sis, will be dragged to the fiery pits of hell when this rate kicks off.

As will you Rocket, considering what you did to MIAMTEC

[Rocket]

Originally posted by BeBeMint

As will you Rocket, considering what you did to MIAMTEC

12 of the 16 tracks all received scores over 5.

10 of them received scores of 6 and higher.

[Sissy]

It doesn't matter, I just made up to God whatever the sinners did to MIAMTEC.

[Superiore]

Originally posted by Sissy

It doesn't matter, I just made up to God whatever the sinners did to MIAMTEC.

As long as you didn't make up for the title track mess too, it's all fine!

[Sissy]

Originally posted by Superiore

As long as you didn't make up for the title track mess too, it's all fine!

Just hypothetically speaking, what if I did?

[BadMouthBetsy]

The anticipation
http://media.giphy.com/media/zv8JtHs...iphy.gif?w=780

[BadMouthBetsy]

Originally posted by Sissy

Just hypothetically speaking, what if I did?

messy

[Pecinta Mariah]

Originally posted by lovesong

This!!!

I think Fantasy has won like 3 or 4 rates already I always preferred Always Be My Baby from that album anyway.

I want the winner to be a fan-favourite album track or maybe a lesser known single.

I know, I love fantasy to death but I hope another song will win

[BeBeMint]

Originally posted by Sissy

It doesn't matter, I just made up to God whatever the sinners did to MIAMTEC.

YAAAASSS! You are the savior of this rate

[Superiore]

Originally posted by Sissy

Just hypothetically speaking, what if I did?

I love the whole album but.. Sissy, SIS!