[QueenBeyoncé]

Originally posted by Slayonce

It's been 15 years already. Anything more recent?

I'm afraid not.

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Kisuke

And still got outsold Proving your theories false.

It's not a theory if it's backed up by the charts. Never said Telephone/BL were her best-selling songs, so saying this proves nothing to the actual discussion, is in theory, off-topic. You've yet to remain on-topic and discuss the question I provided: Why are the two collaborations her biggest hits WW on charts (peak wise)?

[GrandMomCookies]

Originally posted by Kisuke

And boy went to nr1 in more places and loose my breath has more points on mediatraffic then Telephone.

I really do not know why the op made this thread aside from asking for a backfire.

I hype is my boo but his a lil confused right now

[Golden]

the backfire in this thread is to die for. Poor OP

[J a y]

Originally posted by Ignacio

Some don't shoot for Gold albums when they outsell other's discographies with their first two albums.

Pure talent.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Timber

See Bootylicious at #20 even though it went #1.

But biggest is not defined by peak almost everyone knows that.

[idkher]

I had no idea Telephone was her biggest hit Kind of shocking

[Timber]

Originally posted by iHype.

For the 12th time, the OP says this is chart peak wise. Telling me they weren't bigger on charts overall serves no purpose, as I never said they were.

I just said "Why are they her biggest hits WW chart peak wise?". It's proven that Beautiful Liar & Telephone had more higher peaks WW.

Well you're title is lying then. You should fix that.

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Golden

the backfire in this thread is to die for. Poor OP

There's no backfire. Everyone who isn't the Hive, who defends Beyonce to the highest point in everything, has agreed.

+ the replies actually served what I wanted when making this thread. But I won't get into that.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by iHype.

It's not a theory

Sadly it is.

Sl and halo are both bigger then telephone and thats why you have been ignoring everyone here since page one.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Golden

the backfire in this thread is to die for. Poor OP

Even the monsters are scalping

[GrandMomCookies]

Originally posted by Timber

From 2011. Notice my point above.

16. Me, Myself, & I (Peak: #4)

15. Soldier (Peak: #3)

14. 03' Bonnie & Clyde (Peak #4)

13. No, No, No (Peak: #3)

12. Naughty Girl (Peak: #3)

11. Bills, Bills, Bills (Peak: #1)

10. Survivor (Peak: #2)

9. Lose My Breath (Peak #3)

8. Say My Name (Peak: #1)

7. Jumpin, Jumpin (Peak: #3)

6. Single Ladies (Peak: #1)

5. Check On It (Peak: #1)

4. Crazy In Love (Peak #1)

3. Baby Boy (Peak: #1)

2. Irreplaceable (Peak: #1)

1. Independent Women Pt. 1 (Peak: #1)


So Beyoncé have 16 songs bigger then telephone

[Golden]

Originally posted by iHype.

There's no backfire. Everyone who isn't the Hive, who defends Beyonce to the highest point in everything, has agreed.

+ the replies actually served what I wanted when making this thread. But I won't get into that.

Who cares about bigger peaks when you can sell more? Would you rather want a #1 peaking album that sells 2 million copies or do you want a #7 peaking album that goes on to sell 5 million copies?

Your flawed logic is truly appalling.

[QueenBeyoncé]

Originally posted by idkher

I had no idea Telephone was her biggest hit Kind of shocking

Even IIWAB peaked in #1 in more countries. Halo outsold.

[GrandMomCookies]

I need answers

Billboard just say Beyoncé has 16 bigger songs then telephone

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by GrandMomCookies

16. Me, Myself, & I (Peak: #4)

15. Soldier (Peak: #3)

14. 03' Bonnie & Clyde (Peak #4)

13. No, No, No (Peak: #3)

12. Naughty Girl (Peak: #3)

11. Bills, Bills, Bills (Peak: #1)

10. Survivor (Peak: #2)

9. Lose My Breath (Peak #3)

8. Say My Name (Peak: #1)

7. Jumpin, Jumpin (Peak: #3)

6. Single Ladies (Peak: #1)

5. Check On It (Peak: #1)

4. Crazy In Love (Peak #1)

3. Baby Boy (Peak: #1)

2. Irreplaceable (Peak: #1)

1. Independent Women Pt. 1 (Peak: #1)


So Beyoncé have 16 songs bigger then telephone

But Ihype said peaks mean songs are bigger

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Kisuke

Even the monsters are scalping

No, they aren't please show this. The fact you result to lies when wrong in threads is awkward.

[Timber]

Originally posted by QueenBeyoncé

Even IIWAB peaked in #1 in more countries. Halo outsold.

Halo is such a classic. It will continue to sell for a long while.

[Bayonsay]

Originally posted by idkher

I had no idea Telephone was her biggest hit Kind of shocking

Except it's not.

[Istan4R]

I cant believe SL only hit number 1 in US. I guess she is local