No, it isn't. The anatomical structure is generally that of a Lyric fach. That puts certain chains on one's voice, although there are those select few who break free of their binds and exceed their innate capacity (namely Mariah, Kelly, Carrie). Jennifer's tract is uncommon. She's a Spinto voice in the transition to Dramatic. Those facher are extremely rare. Jennifer's voice not only has an innate affinity in Fortissimo but Pianissimo as well whereas Beyonce's confined to only one.
Again, I'm judging the voice itself. Beyonce's voice is a wikipedia article. You can find it anywhere. She doesn't bypass the capacity of her voice. She sings within her natural parameters and has no ability to exceed them. It's feeble. I think Jennifer's voice is miles better than Beyonce's. That's my opinion. I don't think Beyonce has a good enough voice to compare to a great one like Jennifer's, Christina's or Mariah's or Patti's.
All those words and you still haven't proven a point
No, it isn't. The anatomical structure is generally that of a Lyric fach. That puts certain chains on one's voice, although there are those select few who break free of their binds and exceed their innate capacity (namely Mariah, Kelly, Carrie). Jennifer's tract is uncommon. She's a Spinto voice in the transition to Dramatic. Those facher are extremely rare. Jennifer's voice not only has an innate affinity in Fortissimo but Pianissimo as well whereas Beyonce's confined to only one.
Again, I'm judging the voice itself. Beyonce's voice is a wikipedia article. You can find it anywhere. She doesn't bypass the capacity of her voice. She sings within her natural parameters and has no ability to exceed them. It's feeble. I think Jennifer's voice is miles better than Beyonce's. That's my opinion. I don't think Beyonce has a good enough voice to compare to a great one like Jennifer's, Christina's or Mariah's or Patti's.
How can anyone bypass the capacity of their voice?
How can anyone bypass the capacity of their voice?
Easily. Mariah Carey's a Lyric Soprano who could project her voice near Full Lyric Volume, with an innately small vocal tract. Think before you employ rhetorical questions
No, it isn't. The anatomical structure is generally that of a Lyric fach. That puts certain chains on one's voice, although there are those select few who break free of their binds and exceed their innate capacity (namely Mariah, Kelly, Carrie). Jennifer's tract is uncommon. She's a Spinto voice in the transition to Dramatic. Those facher are extremely rare. Jennifer's voice not only has an innate affinity in Fortissimo but Pianissimo as well whereas Beyonce's confined to only one.
Again, I'm judging the voice itself. Beyonce's voice is a wikipedia article. You can find it anywhere. She doesn't bypass the capacity of her voice. She sings within her natural parameters and has no ability to exceed them. It's feeble. I think Jennifer's voice is miles better than Beyonce's. That's my opinion. I don't think Beyonce has a good enough voice to compare to a great one like Jennifer's, Christina's or Mariah's or Patti's.
You mean the screamers?
Talking about "bypassing the capacity of her voice"... Are you kidding me? Do you know what happens when you do that?
And even when you do it with a relatively neutral larynx and none of that weird heavy breathing Jennifer Hudson does, eventually your voice will suffer. Just like Mariah's deteriorated much faster than it would have if she didn't have to do all that 5th octave belting in the 90s, because she already had nodules.
And if you think that belting is what makes you a true vocalist you don't know **** about music. Musicality >>>>>> "Belting" a chesty high note, which in the case of some of your faves would be screaming a thin and shrill high note.
Listening to this, would you say that she isn't much of a vocalist because she isn't scream... ah.. I mean "bypassing her vocal capacity" like Christina Aguilera?
Talking about "bypassing the capacity of her voice"... Are you kidding me? Do you know what happens when you do that?
And even when you do it with a relatively neutral larynx and none of that weird heavy breathing Jennifer Hudson does, eventually your voice will suffer. Just like Mariah's deteriorated much faster than it would have if she didn't have to do all that 5th octave belting in the 90s, because she already had nodules.
And if you think that belting is what makes you a true vocalist you don't know **** about music. Musicality >>>>>> "Belting" a chesty high note, which in the case of some of your faves would be screaming a thin and shrill high note.
Listening to this, would you say that she isn't much of a vocalist because she isn't scream... ah.. I mean "bypassing her vocal capacity" like Christina Aguilera?
IDK...I think a lot of people connect with Xtina, Patti's, and J Hud's "screamer" voices as you call it, because they are giving it all in their performances...like a gospel singer at church. It's not to say Beyonce couldn't belt like they do...but because she doesn't, many of her song's sound restrained and hollowed...
Personally... Love On Top is my favorite Beyonce song... she at least sings with some intensity not found on many of her other songs....though X, J Hud, Patti, or even Alicia would show her up if they took a crack at Love On Top, because they are simply more emotive singers than Bey.
IDK...I think a lot of people connect with Xtina, Patti's, and J Hud's "screamer" voices as you call it, because they are giving it all in their performances...like a gospel singer at church. It's not to say Beyonce couldn't belt like they do...but because she doesn't, many of her song's sound restrained and hollowed...
Personally... Love On Top is my favorite Beyonce song... she at least sings with some intensity not found on many of her other songs....though X, J Hud, Patti, or even Alicia would show her up if they took a crack at Love On Top, because they are simply more emotive singers than Bey.
Alicia can't even belt the main chorus of Love on Top without sounding like she's gonna hurl. X can't even attempt the verses and J Hudson, idk... she'd just start screaming. I'll post videos of all these singers attempting similar notes in a minute.
Patti slays everyone.
Edit:
Love on Top showcase, she's belting E5's in the chorus
Here's Christina Aguilera's E5 @ 4:50
Barely audible. All the other attempts are like that. That's not singing.
Alicia Keys E5s @ 6:56
The struggle....
Those are just notes they should be able to sing in the main chorus. One can't produce sound and the other sounds like she's about to crack any minute.
Bey's crystal clear, vibrato filled and resonant E5s on the other hand
And her songs aren't restrained, she just doesn't have to struggle to sing the notes. Just because it's effortless for her doesn't mean she does it without emoting. Beyoncé is very dramatic and very emotive. Resentment, 1+1, Heaven and Ring the Alarm being great examples of her emotive singing.
IDK...I think a lot of people connect with Xtina, Patti's, and J Hud's "screamer" voices as you call it, because they are giving it all in their performances...like a gospel singer at church. It's not to say Beyonce couldn't belt like they do...but because she doesn't, many of her song's sound restrained and hollowed...
Personally... Love On Top is my favorite Beyonce song... she at least sings with some intensity not found on many of her other songs....though X, J Hud, Patti, or even Alicia would show her up if they took a crack at Love On Top, because they are simply more emotive singers than Bey.
You're speaking to a wall.
Quote:
Originally posted by Ressti
Alicia can't even belt the main chorus of Love on Top without sounding like she's gonna hurl. X can't even attempt the verses and J Hudson, idk... she'd just start screaming. I'll post videos of all these singers attempting similar notes in a minute.
Patti slays everyone.
Edit:
Love on Top showcase, she's belting E5's in the chorus
Here's Christina Aguilera's E5 @ 4:50
Barely audible. All the other attempts are like that. That's not singing.
Alicia Keys E5s @ 6:56
The struggle....
Those are just notes they should be able to sing in the main chorus. One can't produce sound and the other sounds like she's about to crack any minute.
Bey's crystal clear, vibrato filled and resonant E5s on the other hand
And her songs aren't restrained, she just doesn't have to struggle to sing the notes. Just because it's effortless for her doesn't mean she does it without emoting. Beyoncé is very dramatic and very emotive. Resentment, 1+1, Heaven and Ring the Alarm being great examples of her emotive singing.
Beyonce lips Love On Top at least 90%, sit tf down There were several flat E5s in that video by the way lol And I DARE you to tell me 2:40 wasn't lipped. Come on now. A Mezzo. At least Christina is bold enough to take the fail, she doesn't circumvent it with gimmicks
There were several flat E5s in that video by the way lol And I DARE you to tell me 2:40 wasn't lipped. Come on now. A Mezzo. At least Christina is bold enough to take the fail, she doesn't circumvent it with gimmicks