Dylan's Rank:
R8:
1. Demi - Looks official. Better than the official cover actually.
2. Rihanna - Would be cool if the album had a concept like this.
3. Beyonce - I like it!
4. Kanye - Better than the invisible cover.
5. Ariana - Better than the mess of a cover it really has.
6. Katy - Anything's better than the official one.
7. Taylor - The coloring is weird but I like the picture.
8. Ciara - I'm not really a fan but it's not the worst one here either.
9. Xtina - It's cute but she has to have better somewhere.
10. JLo - A little too literal but cute idea. She has better.
11. Avril - Good idea like the Britney album but the pictures they used are't flattering.
12. Nelly - It's just an odd cover with her smiling like a casual picture and the coloring.
Demi to Kanye were great. Ariana and Katy were good but don't look official to me. Taylor to Xtina were okay. Jlo to Nelly were just not the best options available for the artists chosen.
Ethan's Rank:
R8
1. Demi
2. Katy
3. Beyonce
4. Taylor
5. Rihanna
6. Kanye
7. Ciara
8. Ariana
9. Jennifer
10. Christina
11. Nelly
12. Avril
Towards the bottom, they're either boring/basic or the photoshop is really bad. I love the Demi one, it's probably the most interesting picture of her I've ever seen. The Katy one is perfect too, and Beyonce is, obviously, flawless.
Anna's Rank:
best fanmade cover
demi
ciara
ari
ri
katy
kanye
jlo
bey
xtina
taylor
avril
nelly f
Demi’s and Ciara’s look amazingly real, wow. Ri’s is great too, and would be a great contrast to the last album. Avril’s is uneventful, Taylor’s is really pale and Nelly’s has bad colouring.
Nicole's Rank:
Best Fanmade Cover
1. holyground - I think this one is cute and looks the most realistic realistic to me so it is the clear winner!
2. Superiore
3. Truth Teller - What a beautiful cover!
Truly looked to be a special moment between Bey and Blue.
4. Remmy
5. Amaloner -A cover like this would have been a much better fit than the actual cover.
6. Speezy - Anything's better than the actual cover
but Ariana looks so amazing in the video that a better pic could have been used. That one doesn't really do her justice.
7. gotintoririfever1
8. Yvess - I like the concept (Britney: The Singles Collection teas) but they could have used better pics.
9. Gabegabe
10. prezli - Cute idea but the execution is messy.
11. Bey_RihStan - This reminds me of Azealia for some reason. Lol can't imagine Rih having a cover like this. Not really feeling it.
12. DOMINO - Erm, that random city background adds nothing to the cover and just doesn't work. Could have maybe been good without all that.
R8: Best Fanmade Cover
Kinda offended.
I'm sorry. 