[Iris]

Originally posted by Inception

8 Just Dance
7 LoveGame
9 Paparazzi
8 Poker Face
5 Eh Eh
6 Beautiful, Dirty, Rich
6 The Fame
4 Money Honey
5 Starstruck
4 Boys Boys Boys
7 Paper Gangsta
6 Brown Eyes
3 I Like It Rough
3 Summerboy

5.78



9 Bad Romance
7 Alejandro
7 Monster
7 Speechless
9 Dance in the Dark
6 Telephone
7 So Happy I Could Die
7 Teeth

7.37



8 Marry the Night
8 Born This Way
6 Government Hooker
7 Judas
4 Americano
5 Hair
9 Scheisse
9 Bloody Mary
4 Bad Kids
5 Highway Unicorn
8 Heavy Metal Lover
7 Electric Chapel
7 You and I
8 The Edge of Glory

6.78



6 Aura
6 Venus
7 G.U.Y
9 Sexxx Dreams
4 Jewels
6 Manicure
9 Do What U Want
6 ARTPOP
3 Swine
4 Donatella
5 Fashion!
5 Mary Jane Holland
8 Dope
7 Gypsy
8 Applause

6.20

I'm shocked that you gave Applause an 8. I mean ...

[Skywalker]

I like Swine but it, too, could have had an even stronger presence had it kept some its acoustic roots. Ooh lord. I haven't watched Swinefest since October. I might need to pop that in and take another watch and think about what could have been.

[Forevermore]

Originally posted by Meowster

Didn't know you were a Dance in the Dark stan!

It is a solid pop song.

[Skywalker]

Originally posted by Inception

It is a solid pop song.

Indeed, as it is a Madonna rip-off. I like the Ace of Base rip-off more.

[Forevermore]

Originally posted by Meowster

Indeed, as it is a Madonna rip-off. I like the Ace of Base rip-off more.

"Vogue" is a 10, "Dance in the Dark" a 9. I mean when you are inspired by a pop masterpiece, you really cannot go wrong.

[Forevermore]

Originally posted by Gedamara

I'm shocked that you gave Applause an 8. I mean ...

It could be a 7. I was feeling generous.

[Skywalker]

Originally posted by Inception

"Vogue" is a 10, "Dance in the Dark" a 9. I mean when you are inspired by a pop masterpiece, you really cannot go wrong.

That didn't really help Born This Way in that case!

[Komet blu]

Born This Way is such an anthem, tbh. It has that HUGE vibe when I listen to it.

[Forevermore]

Originally posted by Meowster

That didn't really help Born This Way in that case!

'Born This Way' is dragged down by the extra trash that was not needed.

'TFM' really is a concise record.

[Skywalker]

Originally posted by Inception

'Born This Way' is dragged down by the extra trash that was not needed.

'TFM' really is a concise record.

I was referring to Express Your Way the single, not the album.

But I agree. TFM got a higher average than the others for me as well.

[Forevermore]

I mean in due time, I believe the only Gaga track that has a chance at really being viewed as a pop masterpiece in the future is "Bad Romance". That is Gaga in all of her full fledged glory, and it is spectacular.

[Liberdade mi amor]

Still, Born This Way is her best work. This album just sounds BIG.

[Skywalker]

Born This Way (standard) would be a higher averaged album than Monster. It only has two mediocre songs.

[Forevermore]

Originally posted by Meowster

I was referring to Express Your Way the single, not the album.

But I agree. TFM got a higher average than the others for me as well.

Those tracks really are not all that similar. Express Yourself is not a 10 also...

[Komet blu]

Her next alberm should be 9 songs. No more, no less. Written and finished in less than 9 months, preferably.
Take notes, Stef.

[Brunette Ambition]

9 songs are far too less. I still have problems with TFM because of that.

12-13 songs.

[Skywalker]

11-13.

Just to be safe. No leftovers (unless they fork over two extra dollars for the deluxe).

[Komet blu]

The thing is, more songs=more chances of missteps. Reduce BTW, and even AP, to best 9 songs, and they'd be much more enjoyable.

[Forevermore]

7 songs at the most. All of them brilliant. No filler.

[Skywalker]

I still think she should have a Take A Bow moment with her next lead (not the Rihanna filler single).