All those positive reviews coming in and not a single one begin eligible
And seeing that Billboard score on MC is beyond embarrassing

The album is a clear 4/5. There's very little wrong with it. Is it the most exciting or groundbreaking piece of work? Of course not. But it's consistent, precise, and and overall strong body of work from two hugely talented performers. Not sure how any publication could give it less than a 4/5 tbh (especially considering the ones that have don't explain why they did or ignored the actual album and trashed Gaga for being Gaga).