[Fenty The Great]

The song only reached #1 in the US, UK, and Ireland. The song reigned at #1 for 8 weeks and has sold over 1.5 million copies in the US

That's it?

[Nhật Thực]

extremely overrated

[lonnie]

musically? no
success wise? HELL YES!
The song didn't even sell much neither did it top more than 5 international charts, yet some people on her think it's bigger than toxic or umbrella

[liberalmusiclover]

Originally posted by Cherry

No. Everyone knows and love it and it's a classic of this generation. Quit trying to underestimate Beyonce.

And "Umbrella"/"Toxic" were not bigger.

Umbrella was undeniably bigger. It went #1 in many more countries. Toxic is debatable since the US is like the most relevant market and it didn't go #1 here.

[Trent]

Yes, but it is Beyoncé so...

[sadnews]

Considering it was picked as one of best song in 2000's by many music magazines and medias
No.

[liberalmusiclover]

Originally posted by Fenty The Great

That's it?

Yes.

[Fenty The Great]

CIL is Beyonce's biggest song? With 1.5 million sales?

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

What are its total WW sales compared to Toxic and Umbrella?

[Rama]

No, it was exactly as big as both Umbrella and Toxic.

[Honeyßéy]

No.
and there are credible sources to back up those claims.
you all can discredit CIL all you want, but the facts will
still remain.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Harmonic Dreamer

Of course Rihanna turds only look at numbers.
Silly fxaggots. Stick to fingering bussies in the back of the gay clubs.

The ki is dangerously in love sold more then the albums the other songs are on.
Thanks to crazy in love.

Ofcourse the op omitted album sales and focusing on single sales.

[RomaZzzRoma]

yes

[liberalmusiclover]

Originally posted by Fenty The Great

CIL is Beyonce's biggest song? With 1.5 million sales?

Irreplaceable is her biggest. It is a truly underrated song. Nobody ever mentions it here on ATRL even though it is her best song as well.

[lonnie]

Originally posted by Fenty The Great

CIL is Beyonce's biggest song? With 1.5 million sales?

now when you put it this way

[Fenty The Great]

Originally posted by Kisuke

The ki is dangerously in love sold more then the albums the other songs are on.
Thanks to crazy in love.

Ofcourse the op omitted album sales and focusing on single sales.

Maybe because the thread is about the single But I like how you want to change the topic so badly. How typical.

[JustActinUP]

No, it's actually underrated on this website. It's a classic smash hit(2M only in the US) with critical acclaims. The other 2 songs are forgettable.

[liberalmusiclover]

Originally posted by Kisuke

The ki is dangerously in love sold more then the albums the other songs are on.
Thanks to crazy in love.

Ofcourse the op omitted album sales and focusing on single sales.

Good Girl Gone Bad sold over 8 million copies worldwide, in the digital era

[SylMacPer]

Yes!!!

Other songs like Toxic were way bigger than this!

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Fenty The Great

Maybe because the thread is about the single But I like how you want to change the topic so badly. How typical.

Singles are supposed to sell the album, so where is the off topic in crazy in love doing better at what its supposed to do then the other songs ?