[Jay Fenty]

in my opinion pink just does not appeal to gay men by majority. i actually forget about her existence until she comes on an award show and does the same acrobat tricks.

[ejordanjr07]

^ When I went to her concert there were nothing but gay men around me.

I think people may think she is too crude sometimes.

[Madam X]

She is forgettable outside of her hits, doesn't take risks and isn't polarizing.

[A-P-P-L-A-U-S-E]

Originally posted by Money Power Glory

She is forgettable outside of her hits, doesn't take risks and isn't polarizing.

Its sad cuz I remember how fresh she was in the begining of ha career

[Braz]

Originally posted by Jay Fenty

in my opinion pink just does not appeal to gay men by majority. i actually forget about her existence until she comes on an award show and does the same acrobat tricks.

She's done 3 high flying televised performances. How many times has Rihanna lost her breath popping her ***** onstage?

Who's the one trick pony now??

[Braz]

Originally posted by Money Power Glory

She is forgettable outside of her hits, doesn't take risks and isn't polarizing.

Let's reply to this by points:

1- Still having hit songs and albums after a decade long career >>>

2- Going from an R&B sound to making pop/rock a mainstay on Pop radio again and bringing Linda Perry to the forefront of Pop music. >>>>

3- Why should one be polarizing? She's not a battery.

[Grenn-O]

always such an inspiring speech <3

[Underdogs]

She is by far the most successful female musician of her generation, pop music fans consider her to be the queen of pop.

[Braz]

Originally posted by Liafen

Adele is such a no one. Now go back to Sugababes.

Generic popcorn...

This thread stays delivering on failed figures of speech.

[Alpha]

because she aint even close

[Miley Ray Cyrus]

cuz she doesn't want to be?? i guess she is pretty happy with her career atm

[6_INCH_HEELS]

Originally posted by Braz

She's done 3 high flying televised performances. How many times has Rihanna lost her breath popping her ***** onstage?

Who's the one trick pony now??

Didn't I tell you not to come back in here...

[Yooorsh]

Because she isn't, she won't and she can't.

[Prometheus.]

She isn't in the public eye like her contemporaries. Which is a huge turn-off for pop fans.

[dperkins]

Originally posted by Rihinvention

Because she isn't trying to be.

I've said this a lot on ATRL. Pink is just this normal, down-to-earth chick who happens to be a pop star for a living. She's a pop star by career and not by character. If you saw her at the grocery store, you'd be like "OH MY GOD YOU'RE PINK!" and she'd be like "haha yeah man, what's up?" and then you'd just stand there and have a conversation about her kid. Whereas other pop stars would send someone else to do their grocery shopping, or they'd be surrounded by like 4 giant bodyguards.

She's way too humble and gracious for her own good. She has absolutely NO ego or attitude. She's the anti-diva. And people like Madonna are renowned for having a bit of an ego, and being a diva. It's what makes them a next-level celebrity and pop culture icon. Pink is just that really cool, friendly girl. She's the anti-pop star.

Just.. Well said!

Originally posted by AHemsworth

The three artists in my siggy ARE the supreme. And I have no problem admitting that as of lately P!nk has outsold 2/3 of them. I'm secure in the status they have all built and earned. I will not discredit another artist simply because I'm not a fan of them. P!nk has memorable songs and hits. And despite her single chart run (I'm not familiar with) I know she has a big enough fanbase that goes out and buys her albums and concert tickets. When it comes down to it, singles and charts won't define an artist. The artist will. And P!nk has done more for her name to garner respect and admiration from many whether you choose to recognize it. This forum definitely likes to pretend she doesn't exists.

Hell, I'm pretty sure if she was more out there as a celebrity more people would bandwagon her.

[dperkins]

Originally posted by Jay Fenty

in my opinion pink just does not appeal to gay men by majority. i actually forget about her existence until she comes on an award show and does the same acrobat tricks.

This is such a lie. There are different groups of gay people and I know 3 drag queens just here in OKC who impersonate Pink on a regular basis. I also was at a weekly show where a queen came out and did JLAP and EVERYONE was singing along.

I wish people would see what is potentially outside their bubble. I know I could walk into a club and see a million Beyoncé wannabes, and I could go down the street and see a bunch of Britney wannabes or Pink wannabes. The fact is, Pink does have a huge gay following. However, her fans tend to be more like her and not be all "OMG I LOVE PINK" like most gay Britney, Beyoncé and Gaga fans do. But that's also their character. They're big, theatrical divas. Whereas Pink is not. So it tends to follow how her fan base acts in regards to her as well. Which is, loving her music and her as a person, but not talking about her 90% of the day.

[dperkins]

Originally posted by BlueTimberwolf

Her music is generic popcorn with no lasting impact. All her singles sound the same. No one cites her as an influence. And she doesn't have the stats her peers have.

All of this is just such lies. Like so obviously lying that I think you CANT be serious. I mean... I just can't.

[Nhật Thực]

oh ok, if you want to call her or any other pop girl queen of pop, just do it !

but the GP knows who is the true one

[Kisuke]

She lacks star power.

[eleganceislearned]

It's because she's boring, and she's like the Creed/Nickleback of pop. Basing things solely on receipts is short sighted - one must only take a quick scroll through that "Rihanna is Bigger Than Madonna" thread to see this.

Originally posted by swissman

Simply having talent, success and appeal does not get you that title or Kelly Clarkson would be the Queen of Pop. You have to have that certain something, the star quality that sets you above the rest. You have to do things truly different not just "alternative" and you have to be a queen to people, not just a great popstar.

MTE.