**** NO. NO NO NO.
Alecia, girl, you're having problems. I know, friends are important thing for you and I believe you have some incomprehensible crush on Butch but that doesn't mean you can't leave his boring ass in the trash where you found him years ago. Let me tell you something: he's a wannabe rockstar who can't produce timeless songs, just look at your last album, Beth. Are We Are We Are, My Signature Move, Is This Thing On or Run, all of them are nonevents and incredibly mediocre. And they were not even singles (okay, AWAWA was and flopped - I really don't know why
), why do you keep going back to him? You should find someone who at least trying to bring something new to your style, not the typical guitar riffs, distorted vocal effects, cheap drum kicks and annoying background vocals. He ain't god, he ain't nothing.
/end rant.
Carey, do your thing.
(in the last 10 years) 
I liked AWAWA. It got old quickly though. Others were meh. I liked Run only because of the lyrics.