[SelenaTheWinner]

Originally posted by Miley Cyrus

I never said outselling, I said outpeaking their discographies. READ.

Grow Up.

[nicoyuki]

She's had two good singles and her album did ok and all of a sudden she's out peak Demi and Selena. atrl is becoming to predictable, sad, and delusional for any bandwagon to jump on. I believe a list of receipts were posted in the other thread of each girls numbers and Demi and Selena number were better.

[Eglė]

Originally posted by SelenaTheWinner

Grow Up.

You are the one who needs to grow up though.

[Miley Cyrus]

Originally posted by nicoyuki

She's had two good singles and her album did ok and all of a sudden she's out peak Demi and Selena. atrl is becoming to predictable, sad, and delusional for any bandwagon to jump on. I believe a list of receipts were posted in the other thread of each girls numbers and Demi and Selena number were better.

Outpeaked their discographies in the sense that Problem outpeaked all their singles
This is a pop music forum c'mon now people...

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by Eglė

Bitch... You are the one who needs to grow up though.

woo lord look who's talking!

the jokes just write themselves

[alestevens]

Originally posted by Sasha Pieterse

3 days of preorders do not 438k copies sell

Yes, because she spent most of that time inside of iTunes Top 20, which means she was selling. Remove the preorders, and it would have gotten less than 400K

[Liana]

Originally posted by Miley Cyrus

So now that you can't use the label and promo excuses for skyscraper you're gonna blame the weather
It was her choice to release it when she did if there was high demand for it then it doesn't matter what season it is + you're forgetting that there was hype for Skyscraper for her little rehab stint.

Lol you know damn well it's true and it barely got any airplay and don't you think it's too early to brag? Let Ariana score a hit without a feature artist and let her actually outperform Demi and Selena's careers first and let's where she stands after 5 years...

[ryanpittman97]

Originally posted by Rob_Matteo

And yet she's still not outselling Demi and Selena significantly in album sales especially compared to their debut albums...

Yours Truly has already outsold DEMI and Stars Dance in the US.

[nicoyuki]

One single out peaking them doesn't really matter when you're looking at the bigger picture. I'd rather have Demi and Selena number than problems peak

[SelenaTheWinner]

Originally posted by Eglė

You are the one who needs to grow up though.

[Squall]

How do you explain the fact Yours Truly suddenly came back inside the top 20 on iTunes?
If I'm right, it has not been discounted.

It shows how big Ariana became, it literally NEVER happens even with major pop stars.

[heckinglovato]

Originally posted by ryanpittman97

Yours Truly has already outsold DEMI and Stars Dance in the US.

The world > US.

[Blue Momo!]

Originally posted by SelenaTheWinner

Grow Up.

Originally posted by SelenaTheWinner

I will bring back this thread in a few months... Actually no, I wont cause I have too much class /respect to bash Ariana in any way, cause she is doing Amazing.

You sure do hunty.

Anyway why you mad tho? Isn't Sel coming to slay in a few months?

---
My answer would because the GP are not that interested in Sel or Demi. Although I think Sel has more potential to grow as an artist than Demi. She's more interesting, has better music and seems to have a good work ethic.

[RihannasVeryOwn]

Nobody takes Demi Lovato and Selena Gomez seriously. They're Disney stars.
To the GP, Ariana is just another new young pop star getting her first big break. She's not associated with children's television like they are.

[Liana]

Heart Attack didn't get promo at all in the first month of release, I'm pretty sure Problem would've plummeted just like the rest of her singles too if it didn't get any promo either.

[Sasha.]

Originally posted by alestevens

Yes, because she spent most of that time inside of iTunes Top 20, which means she was selling. Remove the preorders, and it would have gotten less than 400K

no

[mike_10]

Originally posted by MusicLoverDude

Because Ariana isn't on Hollywood Records.

Basically

You can't have huge first week sales with HWR because their timing when it comes to promo is just...

I do think Problem won't be frontloaded as The Way but still, we should wait to see what happens with those overall sales

[Squall]

Originally posted by mike_10

Basically

You can't have huge first week sales with HWR because their timing when it comes to promo is just...

Originally posted by Squall

I don't get why you all blame HWR. This is SO easy.
Just because they made some messy eras in the past does not mean they are still bad.

They promoted C&GI (+ probably a high budget video) & HA (less than C&GI if I'm right but still), they sent the songs to radios, they did everything another label would have done.

It is NOT HWR's fault if C&GI/HA did not blew up (even tho they were still success at least in the US).
Problem has been out for a week, radios completely LOVE it (more than any Demi or Selena song) and it has just debuted with 438k copies.
Ariana became bigger when she literally had anything to justify it (4th biggest opening for a female single when the 3 others are Taylor, Katy & Gaga aka artists that had huge eras to pull out those sales...while Ariana sold about 430k copies of Yours Truly in the US).

No point with their labels. Just no, don't.

Please, you are being delusional guys.

[BritneyFatale]

Didn't every Selena and Demi album outsell Yours Truly though. I know for a fact Selena's did at least

[SelenaTheWinner]

Originally posted by Blue Momo!

You sure do hunty.

Anyway why you mad tho? Isn't Sel coming to slay in a few months?

---
The best answer would because the GP are not that interested in Sel or Demi. Although I think Sel has more potential to grow as an artist than Demi. She's more interesting, has better music and seems to have a good work ethic.

Who said Im mad? And Im just laughing at some of the comments. I treat people, the way they treat me.