[BPD]

Originally posted by Keon

She'll be iconic eventually.

That's already been established


Not that she will eventually become iconic because she already IS ICONIC

[Rick]

She once was a very successful solo artist.

[Concrete]

Originally posted by BPD

We're still waiting for those reciepts hun...

Lol!

It's called tv by the numbers

Season 5 had all time low finale numbers and lower average than season 4

Mess

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/liv...ormance-666243

http://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/201...slides/223414/

I was told that a detailed comparison of season 4 and 5 ratings thread was closed

I'd like to make another one if I don't get in trouble for it. I'd also like to point out that the episodes she performed her Lotus singles in Season 3 were among the lowest rated of that cycle as well. If I'm allowed to make a thread, I would later. If not, I'll post receipts for that later in this one

[InsureTer]

Originally posted by bijonse

Beyoncé-120 million+ records from 5 albums

Xtina- 100 million records from 7 albums

you sure?

Oh you Beyonce stans need to stop. 120 from what? Honey, Xtina's 1st album sold more than 2 of Beyonce's albums. Please stop with those lies, and stop adding those ringtones sales to record sales.

[Concrete]

Originally posted by Ascension

I agree with this. I think she definitely had her time, but it's very specific to a certain time period and generation.

Britney was the biggest pop star in her prime and indisputably most culturally relevant during the time period of her and Christina's prime and Christina never quite reached those staggering heights -- she was always second fiddle to Britney while Bey was on a different path and trajectory altogether with the group then solo R&B crossover route. Bey has outlasted them so her major moments are cross generational and more relevant with more people of different age groups.

Where the other two are first place in at least one area, Britney for the massive size of her peak and cultural relevance, Bey for her longevity, consistency and ability to remain extremely relevant -- musically and cultually -- for so long; Christina falls behind in both areas.

End thread.

[Yooorsh]

OMG! A whole book stating why Christina is or isn't an iconic artist??

A thread with 20 pages CONFIRMS that Christina isn't only iconic, SHE IS A LEGEND!!

Everybody knows her and HER AMAZING VOCALS.

As Britney is known for being a DANCER?, Beyonce for being an AMAZING performer. Christina for her AMAZING voice as well.

[OhYeahYouMad]

Originally posted by InsureTer

Please, she's more iconic than Beyonce because she sold more than Beyonce as a solo artist.

Wooooo I hollered reading these lies.
So those who outsell someone means their more iconic?

Welp. I guess Britney is more iconic than B and X

[bijonse]

Originally posted by InsureTer

Oh you Beyonce stans need to stop. 120 from what? Honey, Xtina's 1st album sold more than 2 of Beyonce's albums. Please stop with those lies, and stop adding those ringtones sales to record sales.

its not beys fault she can sell across all formats and outsell xtina

and unfortunately xtina's sales couldnt stay as strong as they did for the first two albums

[ladygagas]

Originally posted by BabyJane

Yes, there is a reason she is the voice of a generation, the other two are entertainers, one is iconic for their meltdown the other because she can really put on a show.

I mean even her flops are iconic, Bionic and Lotus made more of an impact than other peoples flops, people are still talking about it.

That's nothing to be proud of, but that's everything you have, so it's ok.

and Britney Spears is not iconic for her meltdown, the Slave performance is still more iconic than anything Christina Aguilera has done.

[rockabyebaby]

Originally posted by bijonse

its not beys fault she can sell across all formats and outsell xtina

and unfortunately xtina's sales couldnt stay as strong as they did for the first two albums

receipts for those '120 million sold" claims?

[BPD]

Originally posted by Concrete

Lol!

It's called tv by the numbers

Season 5 had all time low finale numbers and lower average than season 4

Mess

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/liv...ormance-666243

http://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/201...slides/223414/

I was told that a detailed comparison of season 4 and 5 ratings thread was closed

I'd like to make another one if I don't get in trouble for it. I'd also like to point out that the episodes she performed her Lotus singles in Season 3 were among the lowest rated of that cycle as well. If I'm allowed to make a thread, I would later. If not, I'll post receipts for that later in this one

I can't at you still trying this. .. you said Season 5 with CHRISTINA MARIA AGUILERA hit an ALL TIME SERIES LOW.. yet you still haven't provided me with those reciepts.


The smallest rating season 5 got was 2.5 with over 9 Million viewers.


The smallest rating season 4 got with Shakira was 1.7 with over 5 Million viewers.... AND it hit the series low of 1.7 TWICE.

[bijonse]

Originally posted by rockabyebaby

receipts for those '120 million sold" claims?

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=323424

[MaoMars]

hummm yes

[BossBitch]

Originally posted by bijonse

But she's currently on her biggest era with a name that's definitely bigger than her husband's at this point and MANAGING HERSELF without her father

And the next think you're going to tell me is that it was her idea to release her CD like that and not Jay-Z, right?

If it ain't Matthew it's Jay Z... Bey got passed from father to husband like the feminist~ icon that she is.

[rockabyebaby]

Originally posted by bijonse

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=323424

x 003,670,000 * VIDEOS
x 000,900,000 * THE BEYONCÉ EXPERIENCE LIVE
x 000,650,000 * B'DAY ANTHOLOGY VIDEO ALBUM
x 000,500,000 * I AM... WORLD TOUR
x 000,500,000 * LIVE AT WEMBLEY
x 000,300,000 * LIVE AT ROSELAND: ELEMENTS OF 4
x 000,300,000 * I AM... YOURS: AN INTIMATE PERFORMANCE AT WYNN LAS VEGAS
x 000,200,000 * ABOVE AND BEYONCÉ: VIDEO COLLECTION & DANCE MIXES
x 000,175,000 * LIFE IS BUT A DREAM
x 000,100,000 * SINGLE LADIES (PUT A RING ON IT)
x 000,050,000 * IF I WERE A BOY

x 002,550,000 * SOUNDTRACKS
x 001,800,000 * DREAMGIRLS
x 000,550,000 * THE FIGHTING TEMPTATIONS
x 000,200,000 * CADILLAC RECORDS

x 000,810,000 * LIVE ALBUMS & EPs
x 000,400,000 * LIVE AT WEMBLEY
x 000,200,000 * ABOVE AND BEYONCÉ: VIDEO COLLECTION & DANCE MIXES
x 000,100,000 * IRREEMPLAZABLE
x 000,050,000 * I AM... YOURS: AN INTIMATE PERFORMANCE AT WYNN LAS VEGAS
x 000,050,000 * I AM... WORLD TOUR
x 000,010,000 * 4: THE REMIX

[bijonse]

Originally posted by BossBitch

And the next think you're going to tell me is that it was her idea to release her CD like that and not Jay-Z, right?

If it ain't Matthew it's Jay Z... Bey got passed from father to husband like the feminist~ icon that she is.

idk about the next think I'm gonna say but the next THING I'm going to tell you is that she's been outselling her husband for a while now.

If it ain't her family and her loved ones giving her advice then it's be a professional team hired to handle her career for her like everyone else in the industry. Bey's at the helm of her career like the FEMINIST she is sorry

[bijonse]

Originally posted by rockabyebaby

x 003,670,000 * VIDEOS
x 000,900,000 * THE BEYONCÉ EXPERIENCE LIVE
x 000,650,000 * B'DAY ANTHOLOGY VIDEO ALBUM
x 000,500,000 * I AM... WORLD TOUR
x 000,500,000 * LIVE AT WEMBLEY
x 000,300,000 * LIVE AT ROSELAND: ELEMENTS OF 4
x 000,300,000 * I AM... YOURS: AN INTIMATE PERFORMANCE AT WYNN LAS VEGAS
x 000,200,000 * ABOVE AND BEYONCÉ: VIDEO COLLECTION & DANCE MIXES
x 000,175,000 * LIFE IS BUT A DREAM
x 000,100,000 * SINGLE LADIES (PUT A RING ON IT)
x 000,050,000 * IF I WERE A BOY

x 002,550,000 * SOUNDTRACKS
x 001,800,000 * DREAMGIRLS
x 000,550,000 * THE FIGHTING TEMPTATIONS
x 000,200,000 * CADILLAC RECORDS

x 000,810,000 * LIVE ALBUMS & EPs
x 000,400,000 * LIVE AT WEMBLEY
x 000,200,000 * ABOVE AND BEYONCÉ: VIDEO COLLECTION & DANCE MIXES
x 000,100,000 * IRREEMPLAZABLE
x 000,050,000 * I AM... YOURS: AN INTIMATE PERFORMANCE AT WYNN LAS VEGAS
x 000,050,000 * I AM... WORLD TOUR
x 000,010,000 * 4: THE REMIX

is there a problem?

[rockabyebaby]

Originally posted by bijonse

is there a problem?

Originally posted by bijonse

Beyoncé-120 million+ records from 5 albums

Xtina- 100 million records from 7 albums

you sure?

yes.

[bijonse]

Originally posted by rockabyebaby

yes.

it's not her fault that she has sales coming in from EVERYWHERE

the fact remains that studio releases are where the majority of her sales come from and no matter what way you split it she's outsold xtina

[theerealest]

Originally posted by BossBitch

And the next think you're going to tell me is that it was her idea to release her CD like that and not Jay-Z, right?

If it ain't Matthew it's Jay Z... Bey got passed from father to husband like the feminist~ icon that she is.

Your pressed-ness is embarrassing really