[★NAOKI★]

The innovative production, her restrained vocals, the critical acclaim, the artistic music videos, the fact that this was created after giving birth to Blue Ivy (Ray Of Light was conceived after the birth of Madonna's first child).

What do you guys think? Discuss.

[Princedele21]

No.

[Vespertine]

BEYONCÉ is 10x better, so no

[Giliap]

I think that's blasphemy.

People are overrating the hell out of Beyonce.

[★NAOKI★]

Originally posted by Princedele21

No.

How about you give me your reasons? This one-word response is NOT going to cut it.

[Jameson Teqkilla]

It is her Madonna, True Blue, Like A Prayer, Erotica, Bedtime Stories, AND Ray Of Light.

It is her BEYONCÉ

[Cain]

Artistically? Yes.
I'd piss myself if my faves did a video like Ghost Haunted.

[Maiko]

Ray of Light is one of my favorite albums.

Whether it is better than Ray of Light or not, I think it is the same kind of depth and career defining album as ray of light was.

It has all of the same qualities of Ray of Light AND THEN SOME.

[★NAOKI★]

Originally posted by Cain

Artistically? Yes.
I'd piss myself if my faves did a video like Ghost Haunted.

[Quietly Trek]

I think Ray of Light is far better, but this is a good album. I'd say somewhere around The Velvet Rope.

[Maiko]

Originally posted by Quietly Trek

I think Ray of Light is far better, but this is a good album. I'd say somewhere around The Velvet Rope.

girl bye.

[superben]

Beyonce wishes.

It's her Blackout at most.

[BobBertran1992]

It's her Erotica

[Sahn]

I love the fact that ROL is the first album that comes to people's mind when they think about the ultimate female pop record.

So legendary.

[Яeo.]

It sounds like a remastered 4.

[★NAOKI★]

Originally posted by BobBertran1992

It's her Erotica

I would agree with you, and I thought that at first, but here's the difference:

Erotica had huge backlash.

[Giliap]

Originally posted by J. YONCÉ

It is her Madonna, True Blue, Like A Prayer, Erotica, Bedtime Stories, AND Ray Of Light.

It is her BEYONCÉ

wow, so profound.

what does this even mean?

[abrahamjmr]

It's a career defining album like "Ray of Light" was, that's for sure.

[Maiko]

Originally posted by Sahn

I love the fact that ROL is the first album that comes to people's mind when they think about a GOOD female pop record.

So legendary.

I completely agree. Everytime a pop girl says they have been about to release something deep and monumental, I always hope that it's something as inquisitive and moving as Ray of Light.

This has been the closest thing to it.

Whether it's better or not, I don't care of Beyonce comes #2 to Madonna. It's funny how she's always doing that. lol, Super Bowl, Earnings, always #2 to Madonna.

[DeathRevisited]

Only similarity I notice: their first albums after becoming Mothers.
Where Madonna's reinvention was spiritual, Beyonce's seems to be sexual.
It's more Erotica with hints of janet.