They put Taylor's quote about the ranting email dude and the other dude who said listening to Red was bittersweet from the Vulture article on blindgossip as a blind, and of course all the 1ders on there get it wrong but im also astounded at the lack of reading comprehension everyone else there has.
The part in the article where she says "one of them was a songwriter" is so obviously a comment on herself as the songwriter in the 'bittersweet' relationship. The ranting emailer was a completely different relationship, tho he too was a songwriter. He just is too big a db to see she actually was way too nice to him in the other songs she wrote about him. Before Red. And Treacherous is not about Ranter either.
So many of them get that wrong. I personnally don't believe any songs on Red are about jm.