[MikeyDuff1D]

How long did SOML top iTunes?

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D

How long did SOML top iTunes?

Two and a half daysish.

[Bie]

I believe Midnight Memories album is gonna be their best album. BSE and SOML are so good. Take Me Home failed to beat UAN to become their best album. MM album will do it

[MikeyDuff1D]

Does anybody use 1D's X Factor performances (when they were contestants)? If so, which ones are your faves?

I love The Way You Look Tonight, Nobody Knows, Your Song, Chasing Cars, You Are So Beautiful

[Bie]

Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D

Does anybody use 1D's X Factor performances (when they were contestants)? If so, which ones are your faves?

I love The Way You Look Tonight, Nobody Knows, Your Song, Chasing Cars, You Are So Beautiful

Torn >>> everything else

Harry's vocals on the xfactor are everything

[Wafflecakes]

Torn was by far the best, but X Factor edits the audition/middle round footage so its not really fair to compare it to their (generally mediocre) live performances from the show.

[MikeyDuff1D]

Originally posted by Bie

Torn >>> everything else

Harry's vocals on the xfactor are everything

I forgot bout Torn

This! Did you her his high note at the end of You Are So Beautiful

Part of me misses the kings voice from before it got deeper

[MikeyDuff1D]

Originally posted by WaffleCakes

Torn was by far the best, but X Factor edits the audition/middle round footage so its not really fair to compare it to their (generally mediocre) live performances from the show.

Do you mean the judges home round? That's when they sang Torn. The auditions aren't edited?

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D

Do you mean the judges home round? That's when they sang Torn. The auditions aren't edited?

Yes. They are

Everything other than the live rounds gets touched up. Auditions less so than the later rounds.

The Judges Home performances are the most blatant since they actually record it in the studio then layer it over the video.

[Bie]

Harry's and Liam's vocals on the xfactor were so good. Zayn could never shine his bright that time. But he does now

[Bie]

Originally posted by WaffleCakes

Yes. They are

Everything other than the live rounds gets touched up. Auditions less so than the later rounds.

The Judges Home performances are the most blatant since they actually record it in the studio then layer it ovr the video.

Agree! That's what makes Torn performance on live show so special cos they couldn't edit it when it was live

[MikeyDuff1D]

Originally posted by WaffleCakes

Yes. They are

Everything other than the live rounds gets touched up. Auditions less so than the later rounds.

The Judges Home performances are the most blatant since they actually record it in the studio then layer it over the video.

I don't see it sis.I know they're not live footage, but I don't think the auditions are vocally edited. They would be flawless if they were. In harry's audition his voice cracked and let's not with Louis' performance. All the boys auditions have their flaaws.

[Wafflecakes]

Just compare the auditions to liver performances. The number of bum notes explodes during the live rounds.


So either everyone becomes a shittier singer as the competition goes along or they edit the auditions.

[Bie]

You guys never care about 1D's charts and sales. Did you?

I never saw any of you guys who are very active in this base update their sales in 1D charts and Sales thread.

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by Bie

You guys never care about 1D's charts and sales. Did you?

I never saw any of you guys who are very active in this base update their sales in 1D charts and Sales thread.

I am over in sales all the time

The receipts thread is just boring right now.

[BambiStar]

Welcome back, Bie. Now try to keep it cute, kay?

Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D

I don't see it sis.I know they're not live footage, but I don't think the auditions are vocally edited. They would be flawless if they were. In harry's audition his voice cracked and let's not with Louis' performance. All the boys auditions have their flaaws.

No they definitely do. It was big news when they first started doing it. Obviously they're not going to give them studio quality vocals for an audition, but they definitely edit them to an extent.

[MikeyDuff1D]

Originally posted by WaffleCakes

Just compare the auditions to liver performances. The number of bum notes explodes during the live rounds.


So either everyone becomes a shittier singer as the competition goes along or they edit the auditions.

I'm really not seeing what you're seeing. Their live show performances are still some of their best vocal performances to this day imo. So I don't really see the difference. If anything they sound worse on their auditions thn in live shows.

I think you're wrong this time, Waffles

[Bie]

Bambi, I promise I'll be a good kid now. I know I improved a lot for the last few months. I don't want to be homeless again

No Britney dragging in here. Okay?

[Wafflecakes]

Their live performances were awful....there. I said it

They were vocal disasters on the show. It was hard to find a note that was on pitch in some of their live performances.

[MikeyDuff1D]

Originally posted by BambiStar

Welcome back, Bie. Now try to keep it cute, kay?


No they definitely do. It was big news when they first started doing it. Obviously they're not going to give them studio quality vocals for an audition, but they definitely edit them to an extent.

I think you're referring to that whole brief autotune controversy, but other than that it hasn't really been discussed in the media