[BambiStar]

Originally posted by Waffles_

Eh. I think it is fine to get riled up.

The fragrance is just a symbol that represents their disconnect from the fanbase in the last era.

Whaaaaat. If I was a teen girl you bet your ass I would be lining up to buy this.
I don't see how they're disconnecting with the fanbase by giving their target demographic exactly what they want

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by BambiStar

Whaaaaat. If I was a teen girl you bet your ass I would be lining up to buy this.
I don't see how they're disconnecting with the fanbase by giving their target demographic exactly what they want

I don't agree though.

Even teenage girls don't like to be pandered to. It may work for a while, but it can't last.

[BambiStar]

Literally every somewhat relevant artist has at least one fragrance out now. Rihanna is working on a cologne for men. Even Gaga, the 'most unconventional popstar' has one. I just don't understand where you guys are coming from.

I won't be buying their perfume, obviously. But I am very interested to see what it smells like.

[Wafflecakes]

Lets just agree to disagree


After all. No matter what they do they can never be as tacky as Bieber

Let us thank them for that!

[JungleDisturbia]

I'm with Bambi on this one. Sure, it's quite cringeworthy that they have a fragrance but at the same time it's completely expected because it's a pop star standard. It's no secret that 1D + JB's main demographic are teenage girls so why wouldn't they have a fragrance out?

And Waffles, "it may work for a while", obviously it is working right now and they're not going to be living off this fragrance forever.

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by JungleDisturbia

I'm with Bambi on this one. Sure, it's quite cringeworthy that they have a fragrance but at the same time it's completely expected because it's a pop star standard. It's no secret that 1D + JB's main demographic are teenage girls so why wouldn't they have a fragrance out?

And Waffles, "it may work for a while", obviously it is working right now and they're not going to be living off this fragrance forever.

1. Its not the fragrance that annoys me. It is the absolute lies they are spewing when promoting it.

2. Wasn't referring to the fragrance. Was talking about the pandering.

[JungleDisturbia]

I was one post too late. Right after the "agree to disagree", if I saw that post I wouldn't have posted mine.

But yeah agree to disagree.

[BambiStar]

Yes, let's agree to disagree. Until it's released in stores


I remember Bieber's first fragrance not smelling too horrible... almost nice.
Of course it made you smell like a baby prostitute, but isn't that what young girls & gays go for these days?

[JungleDisturbia]

I've been laughing for the past 20 minutes.

[Troye]

Originally posted by BambiStar

Now that I've sent mine in we can start MWB should get his in and tbh I don't think you'll receive one from Flame


If I worked for Simon I would be fired by now for exposing his money hungry ways

I'm starting to think he's retired from 1D tbh.

Mess. We know that's a euphemism for the dirty deed you do with him every 30 minutes.

Originally posted by Waffles_

Flop TBH

I also didn't get rate from any of our retired "legacy" members like Fiss/Monk/etc. But maybe my PM's didn't get through to the nursing home

ffffffff; I'm DONE.

Originally posted by MWB

"Over Again" deserves a 10 just for the line "Hole in the middle of my heart like a polo."

I never noticed that. Lemme boost my score for Over Again.

Originally posted by BambiStar

I can't believe something so commonplace like a celebrity fragrance is getting y'all so riled up

Not you trying to over-exaggerate the criticism.

[Troye]

Originally posted by JungleDisturbia

I've been laughing for the past 20 minutes.

Serving nursing home realness.

[Jack!]

They should make a male fragrance for us.

[BambiStar]

Originally posted by JungleDisturbia

I've been laughing for the past 20 minutes.

He's one of those guys that just doesn't look good with facial hair tbh.

Originally posted by xDiamondx

[CENTER]

Not you trying to over-exaggerate the criticism.

Who me? But I'm never over-dramatic!

Originally posted by Jack!

They should make a male fragrance for us.

As long as it smells nice and not like Axe then I'd be here for it

[BambiStar]

Why have they not uploaded the next perfume clip? I thought they were doing one every morning?

[Regina George]

Their eyes

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by BambiStar

He's one of those guys that just doesn't look good with facial hair tbh.

It kills me, but I totally agree. It looks terrible

Originally posted by BambiStar

Why have they not uploaded the next perfume clip? I thought they were doing one every morning?

Probably the Niall one. I wouldn't want to release it either

Originally posted by Regina George

Their eyes

Yeah, the squinty outdoors look doesn't suit them.

[Regina George]

And Liam was shirtless for the 872395 time

[Wafflecakes]

Does he even own any shirts?

[BambiStar]

Originally posted by Waffles_

Probably the Niall one. I wouldn't want to release it either

I was thinking this as well. In that case it can wait

Originally posted by Waffles_

Does he even own any shirts?

I think it should be made illegal for him to own shirts

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by BambiStar

I think it should be made illegal for him to own shirts

True tea.

Also.... the stragglers all got in their ballots so I am going to work on tabulating (though I can adjust if I get more, but I don't expect any).

Expect the rate to occur on schedule.