[Gui Blackout]

None of them are legends, but Celine is ridiculously more successful than Janet so she wins.

[T.C]

Can the people saying Celine actually give reasons why other than commercial success? Not one person has done that so far....The only users that have made a a debate for Celine are Brando and Chunk, and even they only used commercial success.

[Mr. Wonder]

Originally posted by tcweh

Can the people saying Celine actually give reasons why other than commercial success?

You.
Won't.
Get.
One.
Because.
There.
Are.
None.

[alkralkra]

Neither are legends.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by tcweh

Celine must be a bigger legend than Madonna, Prince, or Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey aswell then

Yes.

[T.C]

Originally posted by Lately 1814

You.
Won't.
Get.
One.
Because.
There.
Are.
None.

I guess not

[2AM]

Lol, Celine.
Easily.

[Retro]

I'd say Celine.

[ECNEICSNOC]

I'm gonna keep this thread as a receipt that no one on ATRL can come up with a valid reason why Janet isn't a legend or why she isn't bigger than Celine.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

I'm gonna keep this thread as a receipt that no one on ATRL can come up with a valid reason why Janet isn't a legend or why she isn't bigger than Celine.

There are plenty of reasons to argue why Celine is "bigger" than Janet, but that's not really what this thread is about.

[T.C]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

I'm gonna keep this thread as a receipt that no one on ATRL can come up with a valid reason why Janet isn't a legend or why she isn't bigger than Celine.

Originally posted by MrPeanut

There are plenty of reasons to argue why Celine is "bigger" than Janet, but that's not really what this thread is about.

He means "Bigger legend". Can you at least give an actual reason why she's a bigger legend or not?

[ECNEICSNOC]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

There are plenty of reasons to argue why Celine is "bigger" than Janet, but that's not really what this thread is about.

Celine beats Janet in terms of commercial success, no doubt, but that's not what makes a legend. None of the people who said Celine have brought up an valid argument as to why she's a bigger legend that doesn't involve sales/"global" hits.

[Mr. Wonder]

Janet is more successful than Celine when factoring in everything.

[-Alfie-]

Celine by far, she's still topping those box office charts

[T.C]

Originally posted by -Alfie-

Celine by far, she's still topping those box office charts

Oh look, another one.

[KhaleesiMiley]

Celine is a global legend

[simon]

Celine is DEFINITELY a legend. Unfortunately, Janet is not. But, Janet was way more influential.

[dcode78]

DEAD @ Janet not being a legend..but yall cite lessors like Beyonce, Christina, Britney, etc. who she directly influenced!

Yall are delusional.

[Mr. Wonder]

Originally posted by dcode78

DEAD @ Janet not being a legend..but yall cite lessors like Beyonce, Christina, Britney, etc. who she directly influenced!

Yall are delusional.

Isn't the logic just hilarious?

[exfactor003]

in terms of Céline not being a legend as she 'hasn't contributed to the progression of music' or whatever, people will have different views of what a 'legend' is. why would a person abide only by that definition when the term is as vague (and open to interpretation) as a term can be?

Originally posted by tcweh

Can the people saying Celine actually give reasons why other than commercial success?

I'm thinking that a lot of members (non-US users especially) will find Céline to be more memorable than Janet (not to say that Janet isn't a household name around the globe). this likely comes down to her global ubiquity during most members' childhoods, which, yes, was due to her phenomenal commercial success. that, however, is certainly reason enough for some to justifiably claim that she is a bigger legend, especially when they're not as familiar with Janet (and vice versa).