Music Box>>>>Charm.
Her voice was at its peak during diamond box and the ballads are stunning.
Charmbracelet is lyrically good, but its one of my least faves from her. Bringin on the Heartbreak is awesome though. But nothing can stop HERO
Have you watched last nights episode? Mariah WAS ON IT! The best episode of Idol for this season. Just go to that Idol thread and read a back to 10+ pages
The only bad songs on Glitter are If We, Don't Stop and partially Twister, but other than that it's a rather good album that captures perfectly the mood of the film (as bad as it may have been) and showed a new, more risky Mariah, who played it safe most of the time on her previous albums, because even when she started featuring rappers on her songs and all, she always ensured that it was commercial and radio-friendly, while many songs on Glitter aren't.
Twister is a nice ballad and all, but compared to Never Too Far or Lead The Way, it's simply inferior and is something that would've actually fitted perfectly on Charmbracelet.