IASF doesn't flow enough for me. It felt like she released two different EPS and packaged them together.
Exactly. SF (the deluxe edition) is brilliant. Once I came to love Video Phone, it was complete.
The Platinum Edition tracklisting is a mess, unlike the B'Day one, one perfect RnB song after another.
B'Day is the only album I can get through without skipping tracks.
The cohesiveness >>>>
Quote:
Originally posted by Desert Rain
Exactly. SF (the deluxe edition) is brilliant. Once I came to love Video Phone, it was complete.
The Platinum Edition tracklisting is a mess, unlike the B'Day one, one perfect RnB song after another.
Let's be honest here. B'Day and 4 are her most exciting albums. B'Day just makes sense. It pure fire. So much funk. "4" is perfection. The ballads are all impressive and the uptempo's are even more impressive. End of Time alone...
I Am Sasha Fierce has some great tunes on it. I prefer the ballads. That's Why You're Beautiful still impresses me. Single Ladies is great too. People like to pretend like it isn't a good song, but it's a great dance track that sounds completely original. No one else could have pulled it off. Videophone is trash though.
DIL has too many fillers, but the singles + Speechless and Be With You are great.