[Liana]

Originally posted by Glam

I know Lizzie made a lot of impact but Wizards of Waverly Place was huge too.. My friends always talked about it.

Yeah but it was overshadowed by Hannah Montana which didn't allow WOWP to be as big as it could.

[mike_10]

Originally posted by briannaisboss

reaching tbh! i mean, that is what she's most known for.

the word "perhaps" tho

[memi stan]

You Selena Stan's are gonna let Hillary win this?

[mike_10]

Originally posted by memi stan

You Selena Stan's are gonna let Hillary win this?

It's just that i don't understand the question, idk if he's asking who's more relevant right now? or who made more impact?

[Liana]

If the question is asking about their current status, obviously Selena.

But Hilary's impact and success was far greater than anything Selena has ever done.

[briannaisboss]

Originally posted by Glam

If this gets closed though Not a single reported post, no arguing.. Just because it involves Selena and Hilary?

Ch...

I thought it was a good thread
I've seen possibly ever combination of ___ VS ___ with disney girls but I don't think I've seen it this way with these two in particular

[Stepfon]

Who made the bigger impact and is more likely to be remembered?

Hilary and Hilary.

The thread title and the question don't really add up though.

[memi stan]

Originally posted by mike_10

It's just that i don't understand the question, idk if he's asking who's more relevant right now? or who made more impact?

I guess both? Not sure

[Liana]

Originally posted by mike_10

It's just that i don't understand the question, idk if he's asking who's more relevant right now? or who made more impact?

lol same

[iGomezHubby]

Originally posted by memi stan

You Selena Stan's are gonna let Hillary win this?

We aren't delusional like some bases. Hilary is the right answer and we will accept a loss of a poll thats been done countless times on a site like ATRL. Yeah we aren't like that.

[Glam]

Originally posted by Stepfon

Who made the bigger impact and is more likely to be remembered?

Hilary and Hilary.

The thread title and the question don't really add up though.

What should be the question then?

Originally posted by briannaisboss

I thought it was a good thread
I've seen possibly ever combination of ___ VS ___ with disney girls but I don't think I've seen it this way with these two in particular

THANK YOU

[mike_10]

Originally posted by memi stan

I guess both? Not sure

Originally posted by Liana

lol same

I guess i would answer for both cases

More relevant now: Selena Gomez
More impact: Hilary Duff

[gerardsuxx]

Originally posted by Stepfon

Who made the bigger impact and is more likely to be remembered?

Hilary and Hilary.

The thread title and the question don't really add up though.

This.

[emmanuel_punk]

Hilary made it bigger and Selena is still relevant

[DiamondDust]

I think that currently Selena is way more relevant than Hilary, but I don't know if this will translate into lasting success.

[briannaisboss]

Originally posted by iGomezHubby

We aren't delusional like some bases. Hilary is the right answer and we will accept a loss of a poll thats been done countless times on a site like ATRL. Yeah we aren't like that.

according to the poll 16* people are

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by Glam

What should be the question then?

It should have been Bigger Impact.

[Glam]

I edited out the bolded question if that was the source of confusion. Now it's only about relevance. I don't want it closed

[iGomezHubby]

Originally posted by briannaisboss

according to the poll 16* people are

Well that's their problem I voted Hilary

[Right Now]

Lol at this thread.