[atrlster]

Originally posted by pinktennisfreak

You have different taste and that's completely normal.

I love P!nk more during IND era, than during Try This era. And most of her fans do.

Yeah, you're right about it being subjective.

I do see a fair amount of people labeling her last three albums as "generic pop rock" and wishing she'd go back to the creativity of Miss and Try This though

Same kind of thing happened with Kelly Clarkson too. She had her big commercial breakthrough that people worshipped for being catchy yet different (Breakaway) then she revealed her true rock nature (My December) but it flopped And now people have said that the last two of albums of Kelly are pretty "generic pop rock" too.

I wonder why people don't seem to be feeling their more rock stuff as much

[pinktennisfreak]

The funny thing is that P!nk doesn't even like LM and doesn't sing it anymore. M!ssundaztood would have smashed even without that collab. She was pretty much forced to do that. It didn't even appear on her GHSF album.

[like2throw]

Originally posted by atrlster

Yeah, you're right about it being subjective.

I do see a fair amount of people labeling her last three albums as "generic pop rock" and wishing she'd go back to the creativity of Miss and Try This though

Same kind of thing happened with Kelly Clarkson too. She had her big commercial breakthrough that people worshipped for being catchy yet different (Breakaway) then she revealed her true rock nature (My December) but it flopped And now people have said that the last two of albums of Kelly are pretty "generic pop rock" too.

I wonder why people don't seem to be feeling their more rock stuff as much

cause they cant execute the rock genre well.

anyways, Im going with X Tina. I just feel she had a more illustrious career.

[esteee12]

P!nk. Everybody loves an underdog. I don't think i ever want to be as fat as she was few years back. so p!nk hands down>>>>

[Tylerbv]

P!nk >>>>

[missy]

Christina. She seems to have the most fun out of all the pop girls, she just experiments how she wants/does what she wants when she wants. You can tell she doesn't give a single **** about what the media/her fans say about her (sales? bitchy? fat? no1curr). She's legit just enjoying life and laughing at all the haters, fearless enough to stretch out into strange territory (like.. Bionic after B2B? That was left field). I like that. Her career is an adventure; a better story if you will.

I love Pink too though. Her performances have been stellar as of late. I hated Xtina when she came out and was a huge Pink fan. There was a point and time where I was absolutely addicted to Can't Take Me Home. But her consistency puts me off, it seems boring. I wouldn't want that for myself.

[Hunter_13]

Pink.

[ImmaSlave4u]

I'd rather have some sort of success.
Plus Xtina was hot for a while and she has some solid BOPS so obviously.
Legend X

[Giselle]

Christina could slay if she really wanted/tried too. So her.

[K@rm@]

Christina is already a Pop Music Icon that has inspired many of the younger generation of singers and is respected but some of the all time greatest legends in music. SO her.

p!nk might be more consistent now but thats because she never had a peak like Christina and she has been releasing the same music for over a decade.

[Madam X]

Originally posted by like2throw

anyways, Im going with X Tina. I just feel she had a more illustrious career.

Originally posted by missy

Christina. She seems to have the most fun out of all the pop girls, she just experiments how she wants/does what she wants when she wants. You can tell she doesn't give a single **** about what the media/her fans say about her (sales? bitchy? fat? no1curr). She's legit just enjoying life and laughing at all the haters, fearless enough to stretch out into strange territory (like.. Bionic after B2B? That was left field). I like that. Her career is an adventure; a better story if you will.

I love Pink too though. Her performances have been stellar as of late. I hated Xtina when she came out and was a huge Pink fan. There was a point and time where I was absolutely addicted to Can't Take Me Home. But her consistency puts me off, it seems boring. I wouldn't want that for myself.

Originally posted by RaeseanLohan

Christina could slay if she really wanted/tried too. So her.

Originally posted by K@rm@

Christina is already a Pop Music Icon that has inspired many of the younger generation of singers and is respected but some of the all time greatest legends in music. SO her.

p!nk might be more consistent now but thats because she never had a peak like Christina and she has been releasing the same music for over a decade.

+1.

[Nippy'sReceipts]

I'd rather be Xtina. She at least has better and more memorable music in her catalog ( Fighter, Beautiful, Hurt, Aint no Other Man, Genie in a Bottle) & she has a bigger public profile. Emphasis on the word bigger. Pink doesnt have a classic song or album. Xtina's first three albums all are pop gems. She may have epic low points in her career but she also has had higher highs than Pink.

[Cheeerl]

P!nk

[Mr.P!nk]

Originally posted by Nippy'sReceipts

I'd rather be Xtina. She at least has better and more memorable music in her catalog ( Fighter, Beautiful, Hurt, Aint no Other Man, Genie in a Bottle) & she has a bigger public profile. Emphasis on the word bigger. Pink doesnt have a classic song or album. Xtina's first three albums all are pop gems. She may have epic low points in her career but she also has had higher highs than Pink.

The delusion!

P!nk has classic songs: Get the Party Started, Just Like a Pill, Who Knew, U + Ur Hand, So What, Sober, Raise Your Glass, Perfect... Her GH album sold way more than Christina's GH. She's way more consistent, has bigger tours and albums... If it wasn't for M!ssundaztood (A CLASSIC album that inspired too many artists), Stripped wouldn't even exist.

[.Chad.]

I'd honestly have taken Xtina's career up until the Greatest Hits record, and then just retired and counted all my money.

Pink may have more admirable career NOW, but it was such an uphill climb to get there. Years of struggling to be seen on that level.

[atrlster]

Originally posted by .Chad.

I'd honestly have taken Xtina's career up until the Greatest Hits record, and then just retired and counted all my money.

Pink may have more admirable career NOW, but it was such an uphill climb to get there. Years of struggling to be seen on that level.

Right I don't think Pink reached that level until her GH ironically and to many people she's still not on that level. Other people reached that level like on their debut or second album

[Qwerty]

The delusion in this thread.

I would definitely choose P!nk. Christina is NOT a legend. P!nk is not irrelevant.

[Scooby Doo]

Originally posted by Qwerty

The delusion in this thread.

I would definitely choose P!nk. Christina is NOT a legend. P!nk is not irrelevant.

Beyonce stans are growing on me so much lately

Many of them stan for P!nk, plus they obviously know talent if they stan for Bey.

[bobbleheadroger]

Xtina, without a doubt, I would have managed it so much better in the Bionic era... RCA would sit down and let me do the single choices...

[brIt-()nstar]

I would rather have P!nk's.