[Stevie]

Great job so far madonnas, this is already really fun!

"Windowsill" was bad. "Sink The Seine" was pretty good for an interlude, I gave it a 7.5. Should be higher but oh well.

[jose168]

[Dr. Shenanigans]

I was at work all night and missed this.

I don't care that Rising Sand was punched out so quickly, but it didn't deserve all of those zeroes, most of the songs were mediocre 4s, 5s, and 6s.

I'm glad The Turn is out, it is one of the lowest points in her entire discography.

Some of In Rainbows better go tomorrow. I'd much rather Sounds Of Silver remain untouched out of the two.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Dr. Shenanigans

I was at work all night and missed this.

I mostly agree with this, but still its the weakest link.

And I figure I'm gonna do two sets of tens, then once we're in the top 30 do 5 a day. That'll knock it out reasonably fast while still not rushing it.

[jqnetto]

Poor Raising Sand, the second worst drag I've ever seen (Kings of Leon were even more dragged)

Praying for Neon Bible.

And In Rainbows isn't that good, their second worst album of 00s.

[Kingfisher]

jesus christ
Raising Sand did NOT deserve that
giving every ''bad'' song a 0 will make the top 10 decent songs nobody hated, but nobody loved either

[alkralkra]

Raising Sand isn't just "bad," it's offensively bad.

[BnPac]

OMG you started this already? How come I missed this? You probably starts when it's already time to go to bed here.

[BnPac]

Trampled Rose deserved at least a 7, you guys just gave it bad scores because the whole album is trash. The way she sang on it made me think of Polly Jean (yeah that's right) and for that alone I gave it a 10.

I am also mad I gave them so many 1 thinking it was the lowest note acceptable when it was 0.

[alkralkra]

What kind of blasphemy, Grâce. It's just a really bad song.

[like2throw]

I don't understand the Trampled Rose hate myself

[Mastamaind]

Originally posted by jqnetto

Poor Raising Sand, the second worst drag I've ever seen (Kings of Leon were even more dragged)

Praying for Neon Bible.

And In Rainbows isn't that good, their second worst album of 00s.

[jose168]

sister rosetta was the least awful song on that alberm for me, followed by fortune teller

[Eizen]

The massacre

I agree that RS was pretty bad and incredibly boring, but it didn't deserve all those 0s

Btw, my lowest score in the whole rate was a 3 (Stick With Me Baby). You guys are too harsh with the songs that you don't like

[jqnetto]

Originally posted by Mastamaind

Kid A is objectively better than In Rainbows, and I personally prefer Amnesiac.

[Eizen]

Oh, and the next album to be completely eliminated should be Kala.
I'll never understand the acclaim it got

[Kingfisher]

i've been listening to In Rainbows with the bonus tracks scattered through the actual album for years
it's one of my favorite radiohead albums though

Originally posted by Eizen

Oh, and the next album to be completely eliminated should be Kala.
I'll never understand the acclaim it got

p sure a lot of Kala songs are in the top 10 tbh

[like2throw]

Originally posted by jqnetto

Kid A is objectively better than In Rainbows, and I personally prefer Amnesiac.

its not "Objectively" better, especially considering the fact that In Rainbows got more initial acclaim than Kid A did when it was released.

I do however think Kid A is better, but it depends on my mood.

[thediscomonkey]

Originally posted by BnPac

Trampled Rose deserved at least a 7, you guys just gave it bad scores because the whole album is trash. The way she sang on it made me think of Polly Jean (yeah that's right) and for that alone I gave it a 10.

I am also mad I gave them so many 1 thinking it was the lowest note acceptable when it was 0.

Your 1s didn't help much tho.

[Giliap]

Raising Sand must be awful.