[Sanctuary]

This is so unpredictable.

Sooner or Later
Some Girls

It's So Cool could be a lot higher, but it's kinda generic so...

[ImpressiveInstant]

...what the flying ****

[madonnas]

And Girl Gone Wild is still in here

[Dream]

MDNA getting paid dust

I'm Addicted and Love Spent should make the top 100 though.

[Sanctuary]

Originally posted by madonnas

And Girl Gone Wild is still in here

I unironically think GGW deserves Top 20.

.

It will probably be Top 100 at best though

[Retro]

Originally posted by Dream

MDNA getting paid dust

I'm Addicted and Love Spent should make the top 100 though.

If "Love Spent" doesn't there is something very wrong with this rate.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Retro Dance Freak

If "Love Spent" doesn't there is something very wrong with this rate.

It has a chance of not though. People are doing the most on some of her good songs.

[Edge Of Glory]

156.


Ain't No Big Deal - 5.354167
Highest: (9 x1 RatedG2)
Lowest: (0 x1 Strangergab)



I think this is cute. I believe this song was supposed to be on the debut (and her debut single), but something happened, and it went to another band, but it later re-surfaced on the "True Blue" physical singles.

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by Dream

MDNA getting paid dust

I'm Addicted and Love Spent should make the top 100 though.

I think both will be surprisingly high. Or at least Love Spent... but I'm rooting for I'm Addicted too.

[madonnas]

I like it, but it's not anything special.

[Dream]

I don't even remember listening to this song

[Sanctuary]

MDNA as an album probably could have been excluded from this rate, really. A lot of people are still in the irrational hate phase for it and I think it has an unfair disadvantage. People were as harsh on HC in '08, and its reputation has improved significantly (not to say it's good) since. Haters right now are just willing to do the most.

[Dream]

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

MDNA as an album probably could have been excluded from this rate, really. A lot of people are still in the irrational hate phase for it and I think it has an unfair disadvantage. People were as harsh on HC in '08, and its reputation has improved significantly (not to say it's good) since. Haters right now are just willing to do the most.

But then it wouldn't have been a complete discography rate

Although this rate is missing 'Your Honesty' which I'm still pressed about

[madonnas]

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

MDNA as an album probably could have been excluded from this rate, really. A lot of people are still in the irrational hate phase for it and I think it has an unfair disadvantage. People were as harsh on HC in '08, and its reputation has improved significantly (not to say it's good) since. Haters right now are just willing to do the most.

I don't think it should have been excluded, and I DO think it's her worst.... but I don't know. it's really not that good. Love Spent and I'm Addicted, and I'm a Sinner are good. Bday Song is very underrated, and Some Girls, Masterpiece, and GMAYL are decent. The "generic" songs are the worst though, and sometimes she tries too hard to be edgy.

[ImpressiveInstant]

By the way I should've given Let Down Your Guard a 10. What a BOP. It really should've been on Bedtime Stories

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

MDNA as an album probably could have been excluded from this rate, really. A lot of people are still in the irrational hate phase for it and I think it has an unfair disadvantage. People were as harsh on HC in '08, and its reputation has improved significantly (not to say it's good) since. Haters right now are just willing to do the most.

I agree, people are just hopping on the "MDNA is trash" bandwagon and don't judge the songs for what they really are.

Even if I think that it's a mediocre album, I still can recognize its good or great moments.

[Sanctuary]

Originally posted by madonnas

I don't think it should have been excluded, and I DO think it's her worst.... but I don't know. it's really not that good. Love Spent and I'm Addicted, and I'm a Sinner are good. Bday Song is very underrated, and Some Girls, Masterpiece, and GMAYL are decent. The "generic" songs are the worst though, and sometimes she tries too hard to be edgy.

Oh no, it's my lowest rated too. There's just a difference between disliking it and DRAGGING it for filth, which is what's happening here. Am scared for I Don't Give A and Addicted tbh.

[Edge Of Glory]

Let me just tell you guys, every studio album except one has at least one song within the top 50.

[Dream]

Here are my MDNA track rates:

MDNA

130. Girl Gone Wild - 6
131. Gang Bang - 7
132. I'm Addicted - 10
133. Turn Up The Radio - 6
134. Give Me All Your Luvin' - 0
135. Some Girls - 4
136. Superstar - 3
137. I Don't Give A - 2
138. I'm A Sinner- 5
139. Love Spent - 9
140. Masterpiece - 7
141. Falling Free - 5
142. Beautiful Killer - 8
143. I ****ed Up - 5
144. B-Day Song - 1
145. Best Friend - 5

I don't think I was too harsh on it

It just isn't a good album, just like Hard Candy.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Edge Of Glory

Let me just tell you guys, every studio album except one has at least one song within the top 50.

Oh god. MDNA or Hard Candy....
Voices or Love Spent

One of them won't make the top 50

[madonnas]

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

Oh no, it's my lowest rated too. There's just a difference between disliking it and DRAGGING it for filth, which is what's happening here. Am scared for I Don't Give A and Addicted tbh.

I Don't Give a is cute, I probably underrated it. It shouldn't leave now but I wouldn't be mad.