[Arturdork]

Katy Gaga Rihanna are in one leage. Beyonce and Britney are a different one

[ryanpittman97]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

She makes pop music, she is not a POP STAR. Come on. The public has a fairly narrow definition of this in their mind. If you referred to Adele as a pop artist to most of the general public they'd probably come running to her defense about how much more "meaningful" she is than all that and how dare you slander her.

But she is still a popstar regardless of what the general public want to believe, critics classify her music as pop

[Monroe]

Originally posted by Nicole

If we're going by past sales and impact, Madonna should replace Britney.

None of them should be there if we are talking about past sales. The real sales trinity is Celine, Madonna and Mariah.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by ryanpittman97

But she is still a popstar regardless of what the general public want to believe, critics classify her music as pop

Nope, nope. Anyone who can't even bother/need to release a video for a huge smash #1 single is not a pop star in the traditional sense as we all recognize it.

[RobynYoBank]

Originally posted by Monroe

None of them should be there if we are talking about past sales. The real sales trinity is Celine, Madonna and Mariah.

I can count on my left hand how many girls care about or want to be Mariah Carey or Celine Dion (sp?).

[MrPeanut]

Regardless, if we were talking about past average sales/impact then obviously Whitney would be in it.

[T.C]

Originally posted by Monroe

None of them should be there if we are talking about past sales. The real sales trinity is Celine, Madonna and Mariah.

And Whitney. Shes sold near 200 million records with a short discography

[Monroe]

Originally posted by tcweh

And Whitney. Shes sold near 200 million records with a short discography

She's the fourth best selling female artist of all time, so she cant' be apart of the sales trinity. She is apart of the vocal trinity though.

[longjohn9898]

Yes.

She isn't "too new" to be included--in fact, it makes it even more impressive that she's largely matched and in some facets even surpassed the other two in far less time.

[coolcristobal]

Originally posted by hairofglory

But the real trinity is Gaga/Taylor/Adele

Why sis I want to agree with you but I'm not sure how Adele's tour went.

[Twai]

Originally posted by KimFloppible

no. Most people IRL don't like her music. she markets to a very specific crowd. that doesn't mean she isn't talented.

OK sis.

[EOMM92]

I don't think that Gaga should be the one in question..

Just saying

[hector.adriel]

If we're referring to nowdays, If Gaga isn't in the trinity then sure as hell Britney and Beyonce can't be in it either.

[Alexz]

There's no such thing as "trinity" not Beyoncé nor Gaga are on Britney's level.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Alexz

There's no such thing as "trinity" not Beyoncé nor Gaga are on Britney's level.

Right. In the court of public/critical opinion they're both above it.

[hector.adriel]

Originally posted by jinzo

Yeah, she's part of the Trinity. She best represents (alongside Brit and Bey) the best that modern contemporary pop currently has to offer- great singles, great touring force, massive fanbase, great album sales, great critical acclaim.

Close thread.

[EOMM92]

Originally posted by Alexz

There's no such thing as "trinity" not Beyoncé nor Gaga are on Britney's level.

I know, Britney's on reality show judge level nowadays

Gaga and Beyonce are so over that

[hector.adriel]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

Right. In the court of public/critical opinion they're both above it.

I didn't agree with what he said, but this is just.

[Alexz]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

Right. In my head they're both above it.

:kirby:

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Alexz

:kirby:

Oh honey. Go make a poll.