Discussion: [And the winner is...] The Madonna Discography Rate - Page 9

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by kitten****

Is this still open for voting

Please!

He said august 31st is the deadline... I guess it's not on the OP though.

Kitt

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

He said august 31st is the deadline... I guess it's not on the OP though.

Sorry I missed that. I guess I was looking for some type of big bolded/single line capitalizing the date for everyone at the end.

DrownedWorld

Halfway done. I have all of my 10's though.

10s

ECNEICSNOC

Just finished the first two albums and I can't say I was a huge fan. Only 5 songs were really memorable and got more than a 7 from me. Maybe I just like 90s Madonna more. In any event, True Blue and Like A Prayer on deck!

jose168

wow can i change get together to a 10! its grown on me so much

Sanctuary

I had forgotten how terrible I Love New York is. Anyone who rated it above a 5 should be ashamed of themselves/should have their ballots thrown ouT.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

I had forgotten how terrible I Love New York is. Anyone who rated it above a 5 should be ashamed of themselves/should have their ballots thrown ouT.

It's the only song on COADF I gave a 10. I love how it has its disco roots yet references groups like LCD Soundsystem.

Sanctuary

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

It's the only song on COADF I gave a 10. I love how it has its disco roots yet references groups like LCD Soundsystem.

Much like I'm A Sinner on MDNA, I think it's Madonna's track on COADF where the entire point is "look, I'm me! Loud, crude, ****-off Madonna!", almost like a parody of herself. Trying too hard.

It remains a 1.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

Much like I'm A Sinner on MDNA, I think it's Madonna's track on COADF where the entire point is "look, I'm me! Loud, crude, ****-off Madonna!", almost like a parody of herself. Trying too hard.

It remains a 1.

I can see why people think I'm a Sinner is try hard, but I Love New York isn't really "look how crude I am" to me, it's just really really camp.

Ainsworth

I think I'll be sending my rates in tomorrow.

RatedG²

Can I give the rates to you like 20 at a time or do you prefer all 177 at once? It'll give me hand cramps for the latter but it'll be worth it I guess

dannylex

Quote:

Originally posted by Ainsworth

I think I'll be sending my rates in tomorrow.

Same here

Sanctuary

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

I can see why people think I'm a Sinner is try hard, but I Love New York isn't really "look how crude I am" to me, it's just really really camp.

" If you don't like my attitute you can f-off, Just go to Texas, where you can suck George's Bushes dick! / Isn't that where they golf? "

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

" If you don't like my attitute you can f-off, Just go to Texas, where you can suck George's Bushes dick! / Isn't that where they golf? "

See I don't see that as trying to be crude and bossy, just silly and ridiculous.

Sanctuary

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

See I don't see that as trying to be crude and bossy, just silly and ridiculous.

I'm probably just pressed about that line because I'm from Texas. She's toured here like 3 times in 20 years.

Bitch.

*gives Jumpsus a perfect 10*

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

I'm probably just pressed about that line because I'm from Texas. She's toured here like 3 times in 20 years.

Bitch.

*gives Jumpsus a perfect 10*

I gave Jump a 3. I like it though.

And maybe you are pressed?

I think the lyrics were supposed to be laughed at/silly. That's what I like about them.

Icing

Oh I am so tugging Ray of Light.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by Icing

Oh I am SO tugging Ray of Light.

Please just be nice to Swim and Skin

Icing

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

Please just be nice to Swim and Skin

Maybe.

All I know is Frozen is getting annihilated. Straight punched.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by Icing

Maybe.

All I know is Frozen is getting annihilated. Straight punched.

You should punch out The Power of Good-Bore too.