[Dylan']

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

PUK got .. 8.5, 10, .... 1 ?????

daufbvgearkcbv a gaigladfi ufgfey fghrj vgf gerhy ???

so its about luck, if the judges like the song we choose, then we're good, doesn't matter how big of a trash it is! but if judges dont like a perfect song in everyone else's eyes, then it flops!
dont relate it to the fact that it fit the theme perfectly ?

I'LL REMEMBER TO SEND ONLY A MILEY, DEMI OR NICKI SONG FROM THE NEXT ROuNDS THEN...

ummmm i gave u a 8.5. i only took off half a point since i hate the song.

[theREALslimSHADY]

Originally posted by DillonATRL

ummmm i gave u a 8.5. i only took off half a point since i hate the song.

yeah and i really appreciate that!

i was talking about MLD's score! his judging has no mention about the song fitting the theme, but only the fact that he hates the song and that the drummer is ****able?

if he hates the song then diduct 1-3 points and gimme a 7 or 8 .. but atleast see that my song fit the category PERFECTLY! since its a rare happening that an indie debut band gets that big a hit! i'd atleast want a better explanation for a 1.

[theREALslimSHADY]

p.s. i m not mad at ray dillon or four .. i just used demi and nicki for examples of judges' faves...!

[Dylan']

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

p.s. i m not mad at ray dillon or four .. i just used demi and nicki for examples of judges' faves...!

[Ronaldista]

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

if he hates the song then diduct 1-3 points and gimme a 7 or 8 .. i'd atleast want a better explanation for a 1.

yeah I have to say I agree on that. I'm fine with it if the judges don't like the song personally and I get less points for that, but shouldn't at least 50% of the score be determined by how well it fits the theme? if a song that fits the theme but not your personal taste already gets a 1, what are you gonna give a song that you hate and doesn't fit the theme? negative points?

[Dylan']

Originally posted by borntodie

yeah I have to say I agree on that. I'm fine with it if the judges don't like the song personally and I get less points for that, but shouldn't at least 50% of the score be determined by how well it fits the theme? if a song that fits the theme but not your personal taste already gets a 1, what are you gonna give a song that you hate and doesn't fit the theme? negative points?

that's how i do it.
and i literally take off like 1 point if i don't like the song.
but i never made it clear to do that except one round. i just kinda expected it.

[Ronaldista]

Originally posted by DillonATRL

that's how i do it.
and i literally take off like 1 point if i don't like the song.
but i never made it clear to do that except one round. i just kinda expected it.

I know, and I think that's fair and how it should be
it should go without saying, really.

[theREALslimSHADY]

and how should i know if he hates the song "with a passion" or not ?? he should clarify such stuff before the round starts ..

[Dylan']

Originally posted by borntodie

I know, and I think that's fair and how it should be
it should go without saying, really.

[Medo]

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

so its about luck, if the judges like the song we choose, then we're good, doesn't matter how big of a trash it is! but if judges dont like a perfect song in everyone else's eyes, then it flops!
dont relate it to the fact that it fit the theme perfectly ?

I'LL REMEMBER TO SEND ONLY A MILEY, DEMI OR NICKI SONG FROM THE NEXT ROuNDS THEN...

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

i was talking about MLD's score! his judging has no mention about the song fitting the theme, but only the fact that he hates the song and that the drummer is ****able?

if he hates the song then diduct 1-3 points and gimme a 7 or 8 .. but atleast see that my song fit the category PERFECTLY! since its a rare happening that an indie debut band gets that big a hit! i'd atleast want a better explanation for a 1.

[VJoker]

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

PUK got .. 8.5, 10, .... 1 ?????

daufbvgearkcbv a gaigladfi ufgfey fghrj vgf gerhy ???

so its about luck, if the judges like the song we choose, then we're good, doesn't matter how big of a trash it is! but if judges dont like a perfect song in everyone else's eyes, then it flops!
dont relate it to the fact that it fit the theme perfectly ?

I'LL REMEMBER TO SEND ONLY A MILEY, DEMI OR NICKI SONG FROM THE NEXT ROuNDS THEN...

I had the same problem. Especially in my first round. It did fit.
This round was a main reason why I was voted off.

[Dylan']

Originally posted by VJoker

I had the same problem. Especially in my first round. It did fit. That was a main reason why I was voted off.

mld loves selena though

[VJoker]

Originally posted by DillonATRL

mld loves selena though

Not that song though. :/
I also had a same but smaller problem in one round, too. But idk which round it was.

[Dylan']

Originally posted by VJoker

Not that song though. :/
I also had a same but smaller problem in one round, too. But idk which round it was.

i think im fair at least though right?

[VJoker]

Originally posted by DillonATRL

i think im fair at least though right?

Yes!

[TimmyInTheWell]

omg i'm sad our team lost but thank you for my amazing scores judges!!! i'm getting better at this and thank you king MLD for the 10

[theREALslimSHADY]

timmmmmmyy!! haven't talked to you in like three days!! how have you been? stalked someone?

[TimmyInTheWell]

Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY

timmmmmmyy!! haven't talked to you in like three days!! how have you been? stalked someone?

hello my dear flawless slimshady i've been spending more time with my family lmfao. but i'll be sure to make more time for the strangers i talk to on the internet i've been good, SUPER FREAKIN EXCITED because in 3 days i'm going to a x factor taping how bout u boo?

[Luigi]

Mess.

Edit: wait our team lost. Idk who to vote off

[theREALslimSHADY]

Originally posted by TimmyInTheWell

hello my dear flawless slimshady i've been spending more time with my family lmfao. but i'll be sure to make more time for the strangers i talk to on the internet i've been good, SUPER FREAKIN EXCITED because in 3 days i'm going to a x factor taping how bout u boo?

thats so good! good luck for your x factor taping! hope you get some footage!
i have been so less active past weekend, i was gone on a vacation .. ! also, my college is starting from tomorrow, i m so nervous!!