The only people who have truly dominated the scene over all others are Britney (99-2004) and gaga (2008-now) Beyonce is always overshadowed by other acts like the ones you mentioned.
Then how did SHE become the Artist Of the Decade based on RIAA receipts, Billboard receipts, and etc... ?
The only people who have truly dominated the scene over all others are Britney (99-2004) and gaga (2008-now) Beyonce is always overshadowed by other acts like the ones you mentioned.
Take a look at my signature boo. Tells a different story. What the hell are you on?
UMMMMM so where do you weigh in on about Rihanna and Beyonce in 06-07 Bday-Umbrella did she overshadow Rihanna
Yes. Yes she did. Irreplaceable was a bigger hit than Umbrella. The Beyonce Experience was miles better than the GGGB Tour. B'Day's first week sales > GGGB's first week sales. B'Day was more critically acclaimed.
also, to say Bey is r&b and is on par with the pop gurls is a thing to behold. R&B mostly appeals to black folk. Pop appeals to a far bigger market, which tends to have a very very large white demographic. Brit got into homes that no black female could have.
Yes. Yes she did. Irreplaceable was a bigger hit than Umbrella. The Beyonce Experience was miles better than the GGGB Tour. B'Day's first week sales > GGGB's first week sales. B'Day was more critically acclaimed.
Irreplacable was bigger than Umbrella the tour yes acclaim maybe but Rihanna dominated 2007-2008 Beyonce didnt
also, to say Bey is r&b and is on par with the pop gurls is a thing to behold. R&B mostly appeals to black folk. Pop appeals to a far bigger market, which tends to have a very very large white demographic. Brit got into homes that no black female could have.
Basically. Bey's music has always had heavy urban roots.
She's an R&B singer with crossover appeal.
The girls seem not to get that...
If you look at the elements that her music contains, it's contemporary, but it has strong urban roots. Even songs like Radio and Sweet Dream are heavily urban influenced.
And the fact that she's reached white audiences with that urban appeal speaks loud about her and her music.
Irreplacable was bigger than Umbrella the tour yes acclaim maybe but Rihanna dominated 2007-2008 Beyonce didnt
Nope.
Irreplaceable was smashing in 2007. The Beyonce Experience tour was going on in 2007. Late 2008 - Another #1 album. A #1 hit single and a Top 10. But that's when the critical acclaim tanked. I'll give you that.
yes she still managed to steal the spotlight from Gaga dressing like a man, Britney's Tribute, and Katy Perry wearing cheese all from a simple rubbing motion.
I'm thinking...
has she ever DOMINATED over all of the girls at one specific time and the answer is no. 
the tour yes acclaim maybe but Rihanna dominated 2007-2008 Beyonce didnt
