[MP2K]

A mess.

[Fingerprints]

Karmin definitely had a lot to prove with their debut, Pulses. And they didn't.

[seanoh]

Cher and Lea deserve better, they're genuinely talented.

[Temporal]

An ATRL member HAS to be writing for them

[Kool_Aid_King]

Why would they post this article

But yes... these are some sad attempts.

Poor Mariah :/ She had NO promo and YDKWTD could've been big on Urban if it wasn't for the goddamn lack of video which was probably shelved and the messy ass divorce.

[LukaNavy]

Louder didn't deserve to flop

[Vulps]

Billboard is such a mess. This wasn't necessary. And the fact that they're dragging relative newcomers like Cher and Karmin who had very public label troubles while releasing their records is even more ridiculous.

[LoKoPaNdA]

They WENT in. I agree with all of them yes even Lea's.

[Frankmusik]

Lea, Karmin, and Phillip Phillips do NOT deserve that.

[Bloomers]

Some of these albums are pretty good.

Phil, Mariah, 50, and Jennifer Hudson definitely deserved better. Oh well though...

[Johnny Cash]

Originally posted by LONGWAY2GO.

But waiT, where's "Shakira."?

The list is about FLOP albums which automatically excludes Shakira since WW it sold more than all those albums combined

[Ichinaru19]

They did not just go in on Karmina and Phillip Phillips like that

[zach]

Jennifer Lopez - A.K.A.
(FW: 33k; Total: 71k)

Jenny nooo!

I thought it would do 80k+ first week.

[liberalmusiclover]

[Chemical X.]

Originally posted by Beatfreak

That's what I was trying to say. Did you think I was trying to shade him?

No I was agreeing with you!

[TheLastChord]

And People here coming at Billboard when billboard does it once or twice a year and they do it dozens of times each day

[Samuel.]

BB pls..

[superben]

I see an ATRL member has become a Billboard intern

[prézli]

Shut the *** up, Billboard. Pulses is an amazing album.

[mariahcarey]

How dare they call Mariah a flop!



It was an iconic album so Billboard needs to do one!