[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Originally posted by slobro

Yeah, sales estimates for pre-digital era albums tend to be very.. optimistic

Unlike stans, year-end charts never lie

I need to see Taylor's estimates though.

[NewRihannaStan]

Originally posted by Sinister

my fave album from her

Mess . I'm not surprised

[Elusive Chanteuse]

Originally posted by Ozzy8923

THAT much? But every site I've looked at has it around 26/27M so I ain't gon' dispute it cuz those are the same sites I use for Britney's #'s.

Slay Mariah!

Most is probably from Asia with 5 million there. It sold over 2million in Japan alone.

[collin]

American Life is not that bad, sorry. It also aged pretty well. It was for sure ahead of its time.

[Ozzy8923]

Bitch I'm Madonna being the song w/ the most replay value on Rebel Heart.

Originally posted by Elusive Chanteuse

Most is probably from Asia with 5 million there. It sold over 2million in Japan alone.

Mariah kinda cracked Asia more than any other Pop girl.

[Delilah.]

Originally posted by collin

American Life is not that bad, sorry. It also aged pretty well. It was for sure ahead of its time.

prob my fav madonna album its definitely top 3 though

die another day

[Starstruck.]

X Static Process and American Life are LIFE

[Clump]

Originally posted by collin

American Life is not that bad, sorry. It also aged pretty well. It was for sure ahead of its time.

Pretty much the worst album of all time, excluding "Love Profusion"

[slobro]

@Ozzy, according to chartsinfrance

Music Box (1993) :
USA : 10.300.000
Canada : 750.000
Brésil : 250.000+
Argentine : 60.000

Australie : 980.000
Nouvelle-Zélande : 75.000

Japon : 2.200.000
Singapour : 180.000
Corée : 1.100.000
Philippines : 100.000
Taiwan : 500.000
Chine : 300.000
Indonésie : 275.000
Hong Kong : 120.000
Inde : #1

Europe : 7.720.000
- UK : 1.800.000
- France : 1.200.000
- Allemagne : 1.250.000
- Espagne : 450.000
- Italie : 500.000
- Pays-Bas : 625.000 (#1 x12(92))
- Autriche : 110.000 (#1 x11(26)(40))
- Finlande : 47.338
- Suède : 220.000 (#3 (31)(63))
- Suisse : 225.000 (#1 x1(32)(72))
- Norvège : 40.000
- Danemark : 235.000

Afrique du Sud : 100.000
Israël : 60.000

Estimations Mondiales : 26.300.000

They tend to overestimate old albums tho

[2AM]

The UK is no longer in the top three markets, that's now the US/Germany/Japan.
And even with those "three #1's debuts!!!!" still 2M WW.
Learn your PLACE.

[Ozzy8923]

Originally posted by slobro

@Ozzy, according to chartsinfrance

Music Box (1993) :
USA : 10.300.000
Canada : 750.000
Brésil : 250.000+
Argentine : 60.000

Australie : 980.000
Nouvelle-Zélande : 75.000

Japon : 2.200.000
Singapour : 180.000
Corée : 1.100.000
Philippines : 100.000
Taiwan : 500.000
Chine : 300.000
Indonésie : 275.000
Hong Kong : 120.000
Inde : #1

Europe : 7.720.000
- UK : 1.800.000
- France : 1.200.000
- Allemagne : 1.250.000
- Espagne : 450.000
- Italie : 500.000
- Pays-Bas : 625.000 (#1 x12(92))
- Autriche : 110.000 (#1 x11(26)(40))
- Finlande : 47.338
- Suède : 220.000 (#3 (31)(63))
- Suisse : 225.000 (#1 x1(32)(72))
- Norvège : 40.000
- Danemark : 235.000

Afrique du Sud : 100.000
Israël : 60.000

Estimations Mondiales : 26.300.000

Those bargain bin music club 'sales' inflated everybody's sales

So... smash in US/UK/France/Germany/Japan/Australia. Why do people say Mariah isn't/wasn't global?

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Because of my mom I know every word, ad-lib, and whistle note to literally every Moo song up until Memiors

Prisoner >>> every Nicki rap lol

[slobro]

Originally posted by Ozzy8923

So... smash in US/UK/France/Germany/Japan/Australia. Why do people say Mariah isn't/wasn't global?

She was gLObal with Music Box but everything before and after is another story

[Pagan Poetry]

Originally posted by collin

American Life is not that bad, sorry. It also aged pretty well. It was for sure ahead of its time.

Really? Sounded pretty standard for 2003.

[NewRihannaStan]

Originally posted by collin

American Life is not that bad, sorry. It also aged pretty well. It was for sure ahead of its time.

No the album is lackluster . MDNA is better than it ..!

But Die Another Day is amazing .!

[Starstruck.]

Mariah was kinda weak in Europe except for a few albums

I mean 2005 Mimi bombed in Europe except for like 2 countries

[NewRihannaStan]

Originally posted by slobro

She was gLObal with Music Box but everything before and after is another story

Daydream>>>>>

[RichGirlPlanet]

Mariah IS or a WAS the Queen of Asian.
Literally all my current Asian favs cite her.

[Delilah.]

Originally posted by NewRihannaStan

No the album is lackluster . MDNA is better than it ..!

But Die Another Day is amazing .!

madonna burping into the microphone and screaming at her kids for 30 hours is better than MDNA

gang bang is the only redeeming quality

everything else sounds like one giant remix

[collin]

Originally posted by Pagan Poetry

Really? Sounded pretty standard for 2003.

Those electronic influences were not being matched by anyone, lol. Also her rapping was pretty funny/cool I thought Seems to be an unpopular opinion though.