[Sinister]

Originally posted by Ozzy8923

For me, the biggest sales enigma will be Music Box selling 27M. Like, damn, 20M copies outside the US is just...

my fave album from her

[Bounce]

Mariah was so Gl0bal, she's so much better than MaDONE

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by ezra

Bedtime Stories was a flop for a early 90s album. Mariah, Janet, Celine, etc everyone's albums from then stomped all over it.

#3, selling 7M at the time (which using the earlier math translates to 2,476,000 copies in 2012!). Flop.

[collin]

Originally posted by ezra

Bedtime Stories was a flop for a early 90s album. Mariah, Janet, Celine, etc everyone's albums from then stomped all over it.

Aaaaand then they were all over by the late 90s when Madonna STOMPED once again. Stop digging an artGRAVE. God is undraggable.

[G.U.Y. Gaga]

Dragging Madge is only fun for the most part when her really annoying stans are present.

[Sahn]

Celebration #1 Germany #1 France #1 UK #1 Russia #1 Czech Republic #1 Italy #1 Ireland #1 Denmark #1 Mexico #2 Spain #2 New Zealand #2 Portugal #2 Netherlands #3 Canada #3 Norway #3 Japan

ARTPOP #1 US #1 UK #1 Japan #2 Australia #2 Switzerland #2 Italy #2 New Zealand #3 South Korea #3 Canada #3 France #3 Germany #3 Spain #4 Netherlands #4 Norway #4 Portugal #5 Denmark

In terms of units, it is estimated that Celebration has sold about 4 million copies worldwide.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Ezra, you're not even trying to be reasonable. Calling something a flop doesn't make it one, especially since you seem to be allergic to receipts.

[Delilah.]

Originally posted by ezra

Bedtime Stories was a flop for a early 90s album. Mariah, Janet, Celine, etc everyone's albums from then stomped all over it.

and she followed that with the critically acclaimed 20 million selling ray of light

[Ozzy8923]

Originally posted by Elusive Chanteuse

Without You helped.

THAT much? But every site I've looked at has it around 26/27M so I ain't gon' dispute it cuz those are the same sites I use for Britney's #'s.

Slay Mariah!

[Shaliydah88]

American Life (the song) is kinda better than anything Gaga's put out since 2009 though.

[Bounce]

Originally posted by G.U.Y. Gaga

Dragging Madge is only fun for the most part when her really annoying stans are present.

omg yas! I kinda like X/O/X/O so I don't like dragging MaDONE.

[Starstruck.]

Ezra literally digging his own grave by these wiki receipts

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Ray of Light's 20M sales translate to 7,010,000 copies in 2012.

[Ozzy8923]

Originally posted by Sinister

my fave album from her

Erm.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by Bounce

omg yas! I kinda like X/O/X/O so I don't like dragging MaDONE.

bjj

Oh! Thanks.

I mostly get annoyed with the Monsters because most of y'all seem to have this NEED to prove that Gaga is independent from Madonna, so you try to prove this by dragging, but Ezra is not doing a good job. At all.

[NewRihannaStan]

Originally posted by ezra

Bedtime Stories was a flop for a early 90s album. Mariah, Janet, Celine, etc everyone's albums from then stomped all over it.

sadly true . This is Madge's best album it didn't deserve it ... But Madonna was rebuilding herself so I can understand the low numbers. But ROL came and she stomped the girls right back ..

[conseeded]

Originally posted by Bounce

AKA

Love that album.

[NewRihannaStan]

Originally posted by Shaliydah88

American Life (the song) is kinda better than anything Gaga's put out since 2009 though.

Lies . Nothing on that album is remotely good

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by NewRihannaStan

Lies . Nothing on that album is remotely good

Easy Ride is in her top 10 best songs.

[Pagan Poetry]

Glass & Patron is kinda the best song of 2015