[hairofglory]

Originally posted by doitez

Bionic probably wouldn't had flopped since NMT had good reviews
Nicki / Katy wouldn't had dressed so weird but then again Kylie was already doing these outfits before gaga came to the scene but not to Gaga's extent

NMT wouldn't have existed either

woo lord she may be flopping a bit rn but do y'all have short term memory loss or something? she was the biggest name in music for years and remains one of its strongest...you can't just discredit the insane impact she had those first few years just because she isn't doing as well right now

[KylieistBoi]

Let's not act as if Gaga is someone not important. That's just ridiculous

[HOD]

Originally posted by nihility

I mean the whole era like the tour, image, etc... A lot of pop stars (and their teams) were trying to emulate Gaga.

Image wise Circus was a bad copy of Xtina's B2B tbh.
The only video that had the album concept was Circus itself but all the rest was messy and all over the place and don't make me start about the bad photoshoot and artistic direction on that album.
Musically it was perfect though.

[Bayonsay]

Music would have essentially been the same. I still strongly believe Xtina was well on her way to NMT/Bionic sounds and image before Gaga existed but I digress. We'll never know because Gaga came and slayed us all in 08 and she's still here.

[Wildcat]

Let's not act like Gaga didn't change things up when she appeared.
She was one of the biggest names behind the dance trend and i'm sure many popgirls were inspired by her.
There was life before ARTPOP people and she was actually huge back then let's not

[alimonster]

Originally posted by Mattyboy

Gaga struggling to hit gold with ARTPOP? Ke$ha has a platinum album. At least she's a singles artist.. What's Gaga now?

sold out madison square garden
while kesha is doing an avenue in indiana

[johnsuxx]

Originally posted by Instant

That's what I'll do when she will release Venus as the third single: pretend that she never happened

[heartbeats]

Ke$ha changed ELECTROPOP music not Gaga

a mod should close this thread after this authentic comment

[collin]

Originally posted by Mattyboy

Gaga struggling to hit gold with ARTPOP? Ke$ha has a platinum album. At least she's a singles artist.. What's Gaga now?

A singles artist? Then why did Warrior only spawn one top 10?

I'm clearly a huge Ke$ha fan but why do fans get delusional about things like this?
ARTPOP has literally outsold Warrior already and has had two singles that have performed
better than Ke$ha's. Die Young may have peaked higher but Applause has sold just as much.
And Do What U Want snatched C'Mon's weave in like 48 hours.

[Ezekiel]

Originally posted by Mattyboy

Yep. Queen K$ is sitting on top of iTunes now.. Gaga couldn't even reach the top spot with her lead single, being blocked by Katy.

Warrior says differently. Pitbull had to come save the day.

[Daymond1998]

Originally posted by Daymond1998

that was jesus christ

Originally posted by johnsuxx

Jesus did it first

nawt u stealing my jokes

[collin]

Originally posted by heartbeats

Ke$ha changed ELECTROPOP music not Gaga

a mod should close this thread after this authentic comment

Just Dance, Tik Tok, Bad Romance, We R Who We R, Poker Face all had a ton of impact

[Mattyboy]

Originally posted by collin

A singles artist? Then why did Warrior only spawn one top 10?

I'm clearly a huge Ke$ha fan but why do fans get delusional about things like this?
ARTPOP has literally outsold Warrior already and has had two singles that have performed
better than Ke$ha's. Die Young may have peaked higher but Applause has sold just as much.
And Do What U Want snatched C'Mon's weave in like 48 hours.

C'mon has outsold MtN..

[collin]

Originally posted by adderalxr

Warrior says differently. Pitbull had to come save the day.

Don't let the semi-pressed fans that hate Gaga give animals a bad rap

[hairofglory]

Originally posted by heartbeats

Ke$ha changed ELECTROPOP music not Gaga

a mod should close this thread after this authentic comment

Kesha did nothing but dumb Gaga's pop music down. It just seems like she had an impact because no one else was smart enough to do it like Gaga either.

[collin]

Originally posted by Mattyboy

C'mon has outsold MtN..

Yes, C'Mon outsold Gaga's ONLY flop single. Very impressive...

[collin]

Originally posted by hairofglory

Kesha did nothing but dumb Gaga's pop music down. It just seems like she had an impact because no one else was smart enough to do it like Gaga either.

Ke$ha and Gaga might be a part of the same genre but they definitely did things in different ways.
Let's not pretend Ke$ha is a watered down Gaga. I'm sick of that. They actually have such little in common.

[johnsuxx]

Originally posted by collin

A singles artist? Then why did Warrior only spawn one top 10?

I'm clearly a huge Ke$ha fan but why do fans get delusional about things like this?
ARTPOP has literally outsold Warrior already and has had two singles that have performed
better than Ke$ha's. Die Young may have peaked higher but Applause has sold just as much.
And Do What U Want snatched C'Mon's weave in like 48 hours.

C'Mon is near platinum though.

Ke$ha's final 2 singles didn't peak high but they had legs and both crossed Gold.

---

IMO, music wouldn't have been that music different without Gaga besides the strange outfits.

[Bdawg]

The dance trend still would've happened. Especially with major pop artists still doing it such as Britney, Rih, Black Eyed Peas, etc.

now the bigger question would be, how different would it have been if BEP did ever release The Beginning or The End

[SlayMePlease]

Katy should have won Grammys for Teenage Dream.