the other guardian review doesnt count either. they already gave her a 60. they posted two reviews
It does count I think. They counted the two different ones for Robin Thicke (a better example than the other already listed in this thread since the two 'separate publications' actually gave a different score). http://www.metacritic.com/music/blur...critic-reviews
I don't get it, why are people so shocked/laughing at those 4 scores? You all know that Katys highest score prior to Prism is 52/100, right? Those 40s aren't shocking in the slightest.
As long as her score remains above 52 (and in the Green) then Prism has been critically a success by Katys standards.
so just because a site praised the musician that you're so pressed about and dragged your fave, they're an amateur mess? MESS!
No, because the review is genuinely an amateur mess. Prism is OK but let's not get ahead of ourselves, that reviewer isn't even a real person, it's another of Jemuel DaSilva's various identities.
The review is full of mistakes and digs at Gaga, and the reviewer's other articles highlight an obvious bias.
I don't get it, why are people so shocked/laughing at those 4 scores? You all know that Katys highest score prior to Prism is 52/100, right? Those 40s aren't shocking in the slightest.
As long as her score remains above 52 (and in the Green) then Prism has been critically a success by Katys standards.
I don't even try to understand some people anymore.
Quote:
Originally posted by Teen Idle
that reviewer isn't even a real person, it's another of Jemuel DaSilva's various identities
Can you substantiate that argument? It might be something I would be willing to hear provided it's true. If not, don't say it.
I can't believe I just wrote all this out but you asked for evidence
I don't dislike Katy I just don't think Prism's that great and examiner.com is the pits
I'm not seeing enough to justify that accusation. Some writers were critical about Lady Gaga and then someone gave Katy's album a good review. The fact that you're inventing conspiracy theories to avoid the reality of the situation is kind of concerning, to be honest.
I'm not seeing enough to justify that accusation. Some writers were critical about Lady Gaga and then someone gave Katy's album a good review. The fact that you're inventing conspiracy theories to avoid the reality of the situation is kind of concerning, to be honest.
Have you read their other articles? The obsession is real
There is very little ambiguity in that one.
but you asked for evidence
