| |
Discussion: [And the winner is...] The Madonna Discography Rate
Member Since: 3/19/2012
Posts: 5,155
|
Quote:
Originally posted by madonnas
You like Sanctuary, Bedtime Story, Human Nature, and Secret, right?
|
I like Survival, Secret and Human Nature, that's it.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/19/2012
Posts: 5,155
|
Quote:
Originally posted by madonnas
Please just be nice to Swim and Skin  |
Swim is heaven 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/1/2011
Posts: 24,324
|
bedtime stories is so underrated here 
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 2/3/2012
Posts: 10,340
|
Me: Oh God, time for MDNA. I hope I'm not too harsh on the poor thing.
Me ...
Madonna: HAY EY EY E-E-EY
*10*
I have no shame.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/23/2012
Posts: 7,699
|
Y'all better not be so harsh to Cyber-Raga like in the Madonna v Janet v Kylie rate
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 2/3/2012
Posts: 10,340
|
Half done with her studio albums. Here's the state of the union so far 
 Albums and Averages
Erotica = 7.96
COADF = 7.58
American Life = 7.45
LAP = 7.09
MDNA = 6.9
True Blue = 6.2
10s:
Live To Tell
Like A Prayer
Oh Father
Erotica
Deeper and Deeper
Rain
In This Life
Nobody Knows Me
Nothing Fails
Intervention
Die Another Day
Future Lovers
Forbidden Love
Jump
Girl Gone Wild
Some Girls
Love Spent
1s and 0s:
Jimmy Jimmy
Cherish
Did You Do It?
I Love New York
Superstar
I'm A Sinner
Don't worry, the 10s are mostly done and I'm sure the 0s will increase when I listen to her first two albums and HC again. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/17/2012
Posts: 33,611
|
Quote:
Originally posted by GarageGlamorous
Half done with her studio albums. Here's the state of the union so far
Albums and Averages
Erotica = 7.96
COADF = 7.58
American Life = 7.45
LAP = 7.09
MDNA = 6.9
True Blue = 6.2
10s:
Live To Tell
Like A Prayer
Oh Father
Erotica
Deeper and Deeper
Rain
In This Life
Nobody Knows Me
Nothing Fails
Intervention
Die Another Day
Future Lovers
Forbidden Love
Jump
Girl Gone Wild
Some Girls
Love Spent
1s and 0s:
Jimmy Jimmy
Cherish
Did You Do It?
I Love New York
Superstar
I'm A Sinner
Don't worry, the 10s are mostly done and I'm sure the 0s will increase when I listen to her first two albums and HC again. |
Her first album BETTER not have any 1s or 0s... or anything below 6 for that matter. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/29/2012
Posts: 672
|
God this rating was so long, but so worth the time.
Album Averages
1.Madonna 7.88
2. Like a Virgin 6.7
3. True Blue 6.4
4. Like a Prayer 7.18
5. Erotica 6.43
6. Bedtime Stories 5.5
7. Ray of Light 7.86
8. Music 8
9. American Life 7.81
10. Confessions on a Dance Floor 7.57
11. Hard Candy 3.78
12. MDNA 5.22
10s
Think of Me (Madonna)
Angel (Like a Virgin)
Open Your Heart (True Blue)
Live To Tell (True Blue)
La Isla Bonita (True Blue)
Like a Prayer (Like a Prayer)
Express Yourself (Like a Prayer)
Keep It Together (Like a Prayer)
Thief of Hearts (Erotica)
Human Nature (Bedtime Stories)
Ray of Light (Ray of Light)
The Power of Goodbye (Ray of Light)
Paradise (Not For Me) (Music)
Cyber-Raga (Music)
Nothing Fails (American Life)
Hung Up (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Get Together (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Sorry (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Future Lovers (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Girl Gone Wild (MDNA)
Vogue (I'm Breathless)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/17/2012
Posts: 33,611
|
Quote:
Originally posted by FameHooker
God this rating was so long, but so worth the time.
Album Averages
1.Madonna 7.88
2. Like a Virgin 6.7
3. True Blue 6.4
4. Like a Prayer 7.18
5. Erotica 6.43
6. Bedtime Stories 5.5
7. Ray of Light 7.86
8. Music 8
9. American Life 7.81
10. Confessions on a Dance Floor 7.57
11. Hard Candy 3.78
12. MDNA 5.22
10s
Think of Me (Madonna)
Angel (Like a Virgin)
Open Your Heart (True Blue)
Live To Tell (True Blue)
La Isla Bonita (True Blue)
Like a Prayer (Like a Prayer)
Express Yourself (Like a Prayer)
Keep It Together (Like a Prayer)
Thief of Hearts (Erotica)
Human Nature (Bedtime Stories)
Ray of Light (Ray of Light)
The Power of Goodbye (Ray of Light)
Paradise (Not For Me) (Music)
Cyber-Raga (Music)
Nothing Fails (American Life)
Hung Up (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Get Together (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Sorry (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Future Lovers (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Girl Gone Wild (MDNA)
Vogue (I'm Breathless) |
I guess it is hard for new fans to get into Bedtime Stories/Erotica. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/7/2012
Posts: 10,174
|
Quote:
Originally posted by FameHooker
God this rating was so long, but so worth the time.
Album Averages
1.Madonna 7.88
2. Like a Virgin 6.7
3. True Blue 6.4
4. Like a Prayer 7.18
5. Erotica 6.43
6. Bedtime Stories 5.5
7. Ray of Light 7.86
8. Music 8
9. American Life 7.81
10. Confessions on a Dance Floor 7.57
11. Hard Candy 3.78
12. MDNA 5.22
10s
Think of Me (Madonna)
Angel (Like a Virgin)
Open Your Heart (True Blue)
Live To Tell (True Blue)
La Isla Bonita (True Blue)
Like a Prayer (Like a Prayer)
Express Yourself (Like a Prayer)
Keep It Together (Like a Prayer)
Thief of Hearts (Erotica)
Human Nature (Bedtime Stories)
Ray of Light (Ray of Light)
The Power of Goodbye (Ray of Light)
Paradise (Not For Me) (Music)
Cyber-Raga (Music)
Nothing Fails (American Life)
Hung Up (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Get Together (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Sorry (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Future Lovers (Confessions on a Dance Floor)
Girl Gone Wild (MDNA)
Vogue (I'm Breathless) |
And I thought my averages were harsh 
 at the 3.78 for Hard Candy.
Hung Up, Sorry, and Get Together  I gave those a 10 too.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/29/2012
Posts: 672
|
Quote:
Originally posted by madonnas
I guess it is hard for new fans to get into Bedtime Stories/Erotica. |
lol it's not that I'm not into those 2 albums, I love them but they're not her best.
And I wouldn't call myself a 'New fan' i've been listening to made since I was a kid, and well i'm 21 now and I'm still jamming to her.
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Dream
And I thought my averages were harsh
at the 3.78 for Hard Candy.
Hung Up, Sorry, and Get Together I gave those a 10 too.
|
Well, Hard Candy was a ****ty album, it's her worst to date, it only got 3.78 thanks to a couple of songs that I actually like and gave 7's and 8's to.
And you go gurl!   those songs are some of Madge's best! I was going to give Jump a 10 too, but I felt that while it IS good, it's more of a 9.
Maybe I should've... oh well :P
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/17/2012
Posts: 33,611
|
Quote:
Originally posted by FameHooker
lol it's not that I'm not into those 2 albums, I love them but they're not her best.
And I wouldn't call myself a 'New fan' i've been listening to made since I was a kid, and well i'm 21 now and I'm still jamming to her.
|
Hm, yeah I shouldn't have said new fan.... maybe stans? A lot of hardcore stans love Bedtime Stories and Erotica, but people who aren't huge stans usually like those albums less.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/7/2012
Posts: 10,174
|
Quote:
Originally posted by FameHooker
Well, Hard Candy was a ****ty album, it's her worst to date, it only got 3.78 thanks to a couple of songs that I actually like and gave 7's and 8's to.
And you go gurl! those songs are some of Madge's best! I was going to give Jump a 10 too, but I felt that while it IS good, it's more of a 9.
Maybe I should've... oh well :P |
Yeah Hard Candy is awful although my average ended up as a 5 (same with MDNA).
I love the COADF singles, they were the perfect choices
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 2/3/2012
Posts: 10,340
|
I'm having trouble rating ROL. Like, I don't want to be overly stan-ish and give it all 9s and 10s, but....
I think the lowest is a 7 for Shanti Ashtangi so far. But even still... 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/29/2012
Posts: 672
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Dream
Yeah Hard Candy is awful although my average ended up as a 5 (same with MDNA).
I love the COADF singles, they were the perfect choices |
The choices were PERFECT, the videos were amazing, and the tour was OUT OF THIS WORLD, like it couldn't get any more perfect than that era, the music, the fashion, everything was great... and then she gave us Hard Candy... i think that's one of the reasons why I hate it so much, it didn't live to the Confessions awesomeness.
But still MDNA > Hard Candy
MDNA has some pretty good songs like Girl Gone Wild, I'm Addicted, Turn Up The Radio, Beautiful Killer and Masterpiece.
Quote:
Originally posted by madonnas
Hm, yeah I shouldn't have said new fan.... maybe stans? A lot of hardcore stans love Bedtime Stories and Erotica, but people who aren't huge stans usually like those albums less.
|
Well i'm a Madonna stan, but I like COADF, ROL, AL, Music, Madonna, TB, LAP more than Erotica and BS.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/7/2012
Posts: 10,174
|
Quote:
Originally posted by FameHooker
The choices were PERFECT, the videos were amazing, and the tour was OUT OF THIS WORLD, like it couldn't get any more perfect than that era, the music, the fashion, everything was great... and then she gave us Hard Candy... i think that's one of the reasons why I hate it so much, it didn't live to the Confessions awesomeness.
But still MDNA > Hard Candy
MDNA has some pretty good songs like Girl Gone Wild, I'm Addicted, Turn Up The Radio, Beautiful Killer and Masterpiece.
|
I agree, COADF was a fantastic era. Hard Candy does seem like such a letdown if you listen to it right after COADF.
I'm Addicted My only 10 from MDNA.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/17/2012
Posts: 33,611
|
I redid some rates.
Here are my averages 
Madonna: 9
Like a Virgin: 6.55
True Blue: 7.16
Like a Prayer: 8.318
Erotica: 8.857
Bedtime Stories: 8.5
Ray of Light: 8
Music: 8.41 (American Pie dragged it down)
American Life: 6.13
Confessions on a Dance Floor: 5.39
Hard Candy: 6.19
MDNA: 4.75
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/29/2012
Posts: 672
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Dream
I agree, COADF was a fantastic era. Hard Candy does seem like such a letdown if you listen to it right after COADF.
I'm Addicted My only 10 from MDNA. |
I'm Addicted is one of my favorite songs on MDNA, i gave it a 8ish, but my favorite one is Girl Gone Wild, flawless song.
Quote:
Originally posted by madonnas
I redid some rates.
Here are my averages
Madonna: 9
Like a Virgin: 6.55
True Blue: 7.16
Like a Prayer: 8.318
Erotica: 8.857
Bedtime Stories: 8.5
Ray of Light: 8
Music: 8.41 (American Pie dragged it down)
American Life: 6.13
Confessions on a Dance Floor: 5.39
Hard Candy: 6.19
MDNA: 4.75 |
How is this even possible!? D:
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/7/2012
Posts: 10,174
|
Here were my averages (that I already posted on page 4 - such a trendsetter just like Madonna  )
Madonna - 7.38
Like a Virgin - 6.50
True Blue - 6.89
Like a Prayer - 7.64
Erotica - 7.712
Bedtime Stories - 7.55
Ray of Light - 8.21
Music - 7.73
American Life - 6.34
Confessions on a Dance Floor - 7.714
Hard Candy - 5
MDNA - 5
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/17/2012
Posts: 33,611
|
Quote:
Originally posted by FameHooker
I'm Addicted is one of my favorite songs on MDNA, i gave it a 8ish, but my favorite one is Girl Gone Wild, flawless song.
How is this even possible!? D:
|
People were giving Sorry, Jump, Hung Up, and a few other good scores, and I was NOT having it! Desperate times call for desperate measures. I might bump up a few Music scores too. Amazing is not that great, but doesn't deserve a 5...
|
|
|
|
|
|
