Correcting ashuduff's mistake part one, the two albums that are comparable.

LOUD.

I don't want to see the results, I made my vote and I will step out of this thread

Oh, I'd love to see all the comparable reviews and stats now.

The results

Loud and All For You are nearly tied for me, as I like both of them. But they're also both albums that are almost too mainstream for my liking and I can take or leave them. So I voted for Loud, since I like it a little bit more and I'm a Rihanna stan.

Let's compare singles

Doesn't Really Matter = (Only Girl) in the World [really hard for me to choose]

All for You = What's My Name [both songs have their minuses - AfY doesn't really do anything special with its sample, while WMN has that damn Drake verse)

S&M <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Someone to Call My Lover (like, not even close. S&M doesn't have a chorus. IT IS A SINGLE AND DOES NOT POSSESS A CHORUS.)

Why are you so biased?

1. this forum is full of Rihanna stans
2. All For You is 2001 album, most people won't know anything about it, maybe the singles and that's saying much.
3. I see most people are 15-16 years old

Blame your fellow stan ashuduff - he started it.

Would you rather us compare it to Discipline?

All for you still sounds fresh and innovative after 10 years, especially the singles All for you & Someone to call my lover. The videos are all beyond their times as well. I wonder if Loud will meet the same fate?

S&M's chorus is the most memorable part of the song - the chains & whips line is the most memorable thing about it.

That's not the chorus.

That's the BRIDGE. The BRIDGE to the non-existent chorus.

The "come on" part is the opening hook.

Great verses, the best part of the song.

Then that propulsive bridge.

Then nothing. NOTHING. S&M has the same problem as Hold it Against Me - there is no proper chorus.

Listen to Only Girl, which follows the verse-bridge-chorus-verse-chorus-middle 8 structure, and you will see how much S&M sucks.

There should be no comparisons between old (and LEGENDARY) and new artists since no matter what the newest artist will win, simple logic. But I'm kinda biased since I ADORE 80's and 90's music.

Well I don't like these polls but whatever.

For me its....

6. Only Girl
5. All For You
4. What's My Name
3. Doesn't Really Matter
2. Someone to Call My Lover
1. S&M

Rihanna - 11
Janet - 10

Although I do think all 5 songs >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> most other songs on both CD's >>>>>>> S&M

Loud
Only Girl > Doesn't Really Matter
What's My Name < All for You
S&M > Someone to Call My Lover

+1

I love that it's doing good for her, but S&M is far and away my least favorite song on all of Loud.

LOUD still winning.