Madonna - She had just come off of Erotica/SEX book and released 'Bedtime Stories' as an attempt to soften her image up a bit. 'Secret' was a hit as well as 'I'll Remember' and The Girlie Show tour was a success. She is also fresh off of a new reinvention.

Whitney - fresh off of 'The Bodyguard', had the best selling album and single of the past year (1993) and the tour is doing wonders. She's snatching awards left and right and is now a mother as well, she's 'every woman'

Celine Dion - She just had her first #1 hit on the Hot 100 with 'The Power Of Love' and album sales are steady. She's still breaking US ground though she's massively successful throughout Europe.

Mariah Carey - 'Music Box' left the other girls without their edges and she's been snatching #1 hits left and right for the past 4 years. "Hero" was a smash hit and 'Without You' slayed charts globally as well. She still has her good girl image though she's a sex symbol as well and has established herself as one of the premiere vocalists of her generation.

Janet Jackson - The 'Janet' era was her biggest yet on a WW scale. Her tour is doing wonders and every single she releases seems to be going top 5/10 or #1. 'Again' is one of the biggest hits of the year and was even Oscar nominated. She's starred in her first movie and her RS magazine cover snatched wigs left and right.

Toni Braxton - She's brand new but has been collecting top 10 hits, including 'Breathe Again' which is one of the biggest hits of the year. Her debut album is selling massively and is 8x platinum in the states. She's established her self as a force to be reckoned with.

Kylie Minogue - She's really successful in the UK, Australia and throughout Europe.

Mariah, Whitney, Madonna, & Janet

MC.

Mariah, she was like the 2009-2011 Gaga or the 2014-2015 Taylor, aka the most successful and superior to her peers

Mariah and Kylie - ATRL would love the latters cute lil generic bops

Mariah. 1994 was the beginning of her career peak. She would've had as many stans as Gaga did during her peak.

Mariah. She was the biggest female of 1994 in the US and WW.

mariah

On Atrl it would be the same as it is now. Probably Madonna with the most followed by Mariah.

In terms of the GP, if instagram or twitter were around in 1994 then Mariah, Whitney, Janet would probably be the most followed.

Madonna.

I would have definitely stanned for Janet. Kyle probably #2 because of Self-Titled.

Madonna and Mariah wouldn't have released their best albums at that point, so meh. Don't really care for the others that much.

Overall Mariah and Janet would have the most stans, I think.

I'm going with Whitney. TBG era is the biggest ever by a female artist and IWALY is the biggest hit ever by a female artist as well. 'I'm Every Woman' and 'I Have Nothing' were also top 5 hits. Knowing how much ATRL stans for success she'll be first. Not rto mention all the 'Whitney serves' etc threads as she's spectacularly beautiful. She's also a mom now so Bobbi would be labeled the princess and yall would be talking about how she'll slay in 20 years.

Mariah next because 'Musicbox' was second most successful and she's also really hot so you'll have a lot of 'Mariah serves' etc. Threads

There'll be a lot of 'Is Madonna over?' And 'Has Janet surpassed Madonna?' Threads because ATRL is petty.

Janet and Mariah and Whitney
Madonna peaked around LAP/True Blue

I feel like regardless it'll still be Madonna

Michael Jackson would have had a lot of stans as well. He's one of the very few males who would have dominated ATRL.

Madonna.

I would be a Whitney fan

Janet

MJ would have dominated every social media platform in the 80s and 90s.