the guy sings You and I and before he even starts singing Onika says "Oh...is he really gonna sing that song?" and at the end she asks her why he would choose that song. Monsters come in!

it wasn't necessarily shade. she just wanted him to sing a better song that brings out his vocals.

I would question that too.

Ahaha to do what? That's Nicki Minaj and she's a judge in a talent show.

There is enough self-drag, I guess.

aIt's not shade. She just doesn't think he was suited for that song and I would agree with her.

I've never heard him sing before, but obviously he had to have some vocal qualities to make it that far and his rendition was really bad.

I'm a monster and I found nothing wrong with what she said. Nicki has had many opportunities to shade Gaga and she has always said she she respects and likes her.

Where is the shade ?

Then Nicki says "Oh...is he really gonna sing that song?" even before he start singing. she just hate Gaga

Not a Mariah-stan reaching for the heavens in an attempt to pit the Monsters against the Barbz You & I is not the most logical choice for most people to sing, because most will make it sound bad/boring .....

I caught that.

I didn't see it as shade, though. I don't like the song myself, so I would have said the same thing.

She's pressed.

I was thinking that she would not want anyone touch this flawless song.

well in the end she was right.

it was the wrong song choice.

and now he's out of the competition.

he was kinda creepy anyway.

Ha! She recognized the song before he sang a single lyric!

Kiii.
She's great on the show I can't hate

Agreed, I think the reason why You & I did well commercially and critically is that Gaga puts a lot of energy into the vocals to get that retro power ballad feel. It's not a great song to just stand and sing.