But the critics and GP continue to praise her judging style. And the contestants continue to fear singing in front of her because they no she's so tough.

You do realize she isn't shading the song? She is helping him. That isn't a song for anyone else to sing but Gaga. I love how someone can misunderstand something and create a problem out of nothing...

I agree with her, he should have sung Starships, which is a great song that would have showcased his vocal abilities. The falsetto during "we're higher than a mutha****a" is hard to pull off.