CHERYL COLE: The former Girls Aloud vocalist, immortalized in British tabloids and one Lily Allen song, scored a Stateside judging gig after a stint on the U.K. "X Factor" then lost it because of, depending on who you ask, her contract, her (excellent) Geordie accent or general producer/judge finickiness. Nobody told the camera crew, though, and she appeared on two episodes. They stand among her best work. A-
NICOLE SCHERZINGER: The blankest judge; none of her Pussycat Dolls charisma shows at all. Scherzinger was originally slated to co-host, a much better role for her -- but then again, considering how little Steve Jones has to do alone, maybe not. D
I like Cheryl, but she literally had less than 5 minutes of air time, so how she received an "A-" based off that is BEYOND me.
Meanwhile Nicole is bringing personality and needed flare to the show. And as far as talent goes, Nicole sings so much better than Cheryl and that is something that can not even be argued.
These talent shows can't even pretend that they care about the contestants anymore. They're just platforms for the "judges" to boost their profiles. Waste of time.
I like Cheryl, but she literally had less than 5 minutes of air time, so how she received an "A-" based off that is BEYOND me.
Meanwhile Nicole is bringing personality and needed flare to the show. And as far as talent goes, Nicole sings so much better than Cheryl and that is something that can not even be argued.
Making someone's audition all about herself, oh how nice.
I saw this a week ago was going to.post it but....
And LOL even with five.minutes on the show all these critics like.Cheryl better. Nicole with all that screen time can't do nothing right. #oop
I'm sorry Cheryl is pretty but she was boring as ****! Nicole is much better and whoever can't see that needs to get their heads out of Cheryl's ass because the bitch is the definition of basic
Who cares. I think she's doing a good job... And what kind of accent does Cheryl have, it's annoying, is that even a British accent? At the end of the day, Nicole still has the job and Cheryl will never ever make it in the US. Let the girl stay in the UK