right? she never gets a break

They all deserve to win. Each video has its own fantastic concept and some of them are iconic, influential, or just plain awesome.

I guess I'll pick Umbrella.

either that, or they're actually a mediocre band that got too much hype.

Honestly, I'm torn between "Without Me" and "Firework". "Without Me" is only undeserving, in my eyes, because it's the same old Eminem ****, AND it defeated two of the best videos of the decade ("Fell In Love With A Girl" and "Alive"). Then again, "Firework" defeated two superior videos in "Make Some Noise" and "Yonkers".

Ugh. I'll go with "Without Me", because, at least with "Firework", there's the excuse that the fans voted for the winner. There is no such excuse with "Without Me".

As for "Piece of Me", yeah, that group of nominees for that year was particularly poor. Only "Shut Up And Let Me Go" really "deserved" to win, but it never would have won, anyway.

Remixed, sis.

Neither is Eminem, but he only has one vote.

Are the winners chosen by fans some years and not other?

Yeah, the video for "Piece of Me" is not particularly good, but the nominations that year were a mess. At least it won because MTV was paying Britney back for otherwise snubbing her amazing discography over the years. "Firework" was just some embarrassing fan-voted trash.

Piece of Me.

It felt... undeserving. I felt like MTV REALLY wanted her to win all those awards that year to contribute to the "comeback" they were pushing.

I know! And he'd already won for doing the exact same thing in "The Real Slim Shady." It was such a weak choice; the White Stripes REALLY deserved it.

Looking at the list.....I can somehow say..."ALL ARE DESERVING"...

They started doing voting for the 2007 VMAs and beyond iirc

Yes sis! Great meaning, great choreo, suburb special effects! I mean, did you see how many times Adele sat on that chair? Only a bad bitch

Now you are just being a troll.

Firework

Actually, it began in 2006. No video won more than one Moonman that year! No wonder everyone was so baffled about "I Write Sins Not Tragedies" getting VOTY.

Piece of Me. Shut Up and Let Me Go or Forever should have won.

Yes it should have It's a great video.