I loved Chrystal so much and i was upset when he won but his album was actually good, i think other than the 5 minutes of fame American Idol has become a piece of crap show

Kelly and Carrie truely are the only ones that have reached superstar status.

The voters honestly continue sucking, because Adam Lambert, Shibon, and Crystal all deserved to win. Kris and Lee are just...

Idol was amazing this year. The talent was insane.

He was lucky to even won. I swear Simon from the beginning of the season sabotaged the season by praising Lee every week, lol. Guy was plain awful, and I liked him because their was none good that season expect maybe Crystal.

Crystal should've won that season anyways.

Wow, he sounds so ungrateful.

Truth be told though, everything after season 8 has just been horrendous. Idol is done.

Siobhan Magnus >>>

True. I hope this year, Jessica Sanchez can somehow be successful. Although I would love to hear a Colton Dixon and Hollie Cavanagh album too.

queen Haley >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
and Scotty is a quite big new country artist now

I guess he's now wide awake

The first time I heard his voice on that song I just said, "David Cook?" He just won because of Cook and Daughtry's shadow.

It's really sad that these thousands of people auditioning every year thinking that they will sell 1Mil record and be a household name.



P.S. Philip Philips should take notes

Lee DeWyze is pretty popular on some indie internet radio stations.

I think this will work out for him in the end.

If Phillip wins, he would join him.

Who is he? Never heard of him to be honest. I actually don't know anyone who won after Jordin Sparks.