Sounds like someone is looking for more money.

She said the same thing last year before they offered her more money.

I hope she returns!

I think two seasons is enough. It got her name back out there which was the whole reason for doing it anyway.
I want her to do other things (specifically more films). Idol ties her down for a good 3 months, time that could be spent on a film instead.

Why wouldn't she return? This show revived her career :x

I'm undecided about this.

It would be great for her to just have a stable job for a few months where she can be with her kids.

But she hasn't been doing a whole lot of other things. Because obviously she doesn't have time.

Cause auditions with the judges start around the time when her tour is on?

The show is getting lower ratings, she should abandon before it sinks

She got 12 million for her first season, 20 million for the second, 25 million for the 3rd? Get it gorl.

On one hand, she's had 2 hit singles thanks to the show. On the other hand, she's great during auditions/Hollywood week, but is TERRIBLE on the live shows.


I wouldn't mind someone else.

THIS. She should just leave it.

+1 more $$$ please, she has nothing else to do, maybe another album in 2013?

Maybe beacuse of the WW tour???

She should do another last season

So, she wants more money...

yeah but she's gonna tour this year.

Firstly, OTF has hit number ones on iTunes in many countries and #2 on US iTunes with OUT American Idol and then #1 on US iTunes after the video premiere only on Idol.

IIY and Dance Again are moderate hits so again American Idol did nothing for her music and you know it, it surely helped her but not musically.

Secondly, she's doing a great job in everything, that's why THEY want her for another season, so your opinion is irrelevant.

it was cute for what it was, but i would not be mad if she got out now. like previously stated it's a sinking ship

There goes her Forbes ranking

Haha, I was kinda thinking the same.

I don't really know what she'll do without all the exposure American Idol gives her. Does she have the fanbase now to be able to carry her?