With Jennifer Lopez topping Forbes and racking in cash and Mariah Carey smashing WW with her comeback CD, who had the bigger comeback musically?

Now yall are reaching with these threads. Mariah clearly had the bigger musical comeback.

Can a mod put an end to these J.Lo vs. whoever threads please

Mariah by far

Mimi.

Mariah.

Mariah all the way

Mariah , Obviously.

Obviously Mariah. Was this thread made out of bitterness about Jennifer making it to #1 on Forbes' list and in some attempt to undermine her?

It's J.Lo but ATRL delusional memebers will say Mimi.

According to google searches, J.Lo has the greatest musical comeback ahead of Mariah's and Ricky's comebacks.


OTF Alone did wonders and better than We Belong Together itself.

25 #1s in Europe

#3 in the US charts

#1 in the Latin charts

#1 in the UK charts

#1 worldwide single (her 6th number one on the chart making her one of only 10 singers with the most number ones worldwide including The BEP, Britney, Rihanna, Madonna, Bee Gees, George Micheal, The Beatles, Elvis Presley and Micheal Jackson)

3x platinum certifications in the US and 17x platinum certifications worldwide

The most watched video by any female artist.

Almost 1 billion views on YouTube..

J.Lo had a much more successful single without tour and Mariah had a much more succesful album with tour.

That's it ?

Ok let's be honest. On The Floor has sold better in the US and worldwide.

On The Floor
US 3x Platinum
Australia 4× Platinum
Belgium Gold
Denmark Platinum
Finland Platinum
Germany 2× Platinum
Italy Multi-platinum
New Zealand 2× Platinum
Russia Gold
Spain 3× Platinum
Sweden 2× Platinum
Switzerland 3× Platinum
United States 3× Platinum

+ #1 in 25 countries including all the biggest markets in Europe (UK, France and Germany) and also Australia.
+ #1 worldwide single
+ #1 in Latin singles charts
+ #3 in the US
One of the biggest selling singles of all time
Most watched video by a female artist

We Belong Together

Australia Platinum
New Zealand Platinum
US Platinum

#1 Australia
#1 Dutch Singles Charts
#1 US


Not to mention, the mag covers, the google searches making Lopez the greatest musical comeback act since 2004, the most beautiful woman title, the most powerful celebrity, the highest salary for a judge on a television show and the list goes on.

Damn! This woman is the definition of "underrated" on ATRL.

I'd say Mimi. But Jenny is really close. Mimi had the album sales too, not just singles (single in Jenny's case).

Magazines and lists don't count. Musical comeback. Not comeback of a musician. Different things. If it wasn't just about music, Jenny.

Mariah.

Mariah.

OTF was way bigger WW than WBT, tho.

But what about LOVE? Oh wait.

Mimi had the biggest hit of her career